Refusal decisions · 21–27 Sep 2026

61Refusals
43Substantive reasons
3Verification only
1Document not published
5Portal unavailable
9Manual review

What this means

Applications were most often refused because the proposal did not fit its site or surroundings, harmed the amenity of neighbouring homes, conflicted with zoning or rural-housing policy, created access or road-safety problems or lacked enough technical evidence to demonstrate its impacts were acceptable.

43 of 61 records carry official reason text

81 published statements, 1.9 per analysed application

23 refused on more than one ground, up to 5

Most common pairs

  1. 16 Design + Residential amenity
  2. 14 Design + Zoning/policy
  3. 12 Design + Transport/access

All ten refusal themes

Applications · statements
  1. 01 Design, scale, character or visual impact 30
  2. 02 Residential amenity, privacy, light or noise 21
  3. 03 Zoning, land use, settlement policy or rural housing need 20
  4. 04 Traffic, access, parking or road safety 14
  5. 05 Missing or insufficient evidence, surveys or technical detail 14
  6. 06 Unauthorised development, retention or procedural history 11
  7. 07 Built heritage or archaeology 9
  8. 08 Wastewater, effluent, groundwater or public health 6
  9. 09 Surface-water drainage or flood risk 4
  10. 10 Ecology, habitats or Natura impacts 3

Refusal decisions · 21–27 Sep 2026

17 of 17 cards shown · 46 case links · 0 linked projects

The figures at the top of this page are for all of Ireland; this list shows Dublin only.

Refused

Victoria Lane Rear on 1 Hollybank Road, Dublin 9 Dublin, Dublin

Victoria Lane Rear on 1 Hollybank Road, Dublin 9 Dublin

Dublin City Council · WEB2931/26

What was proposed

The development consists of Planning Permission being sought for the conversion of the existing Storage Unit into a garage for the parking of 1No. car. This garage will be in keeping and in line with the rest of the garages to the rear of Hollybank Road and Botanic Avenue. This space will be used for the secure storage of bicycles for the staff of Kennedy’s Public House during the day, with the parking of 1No. car in the evening hours, as there is no parking allowed within the laneway. This proposal entails the provision of a roller shutter to the northern elevation with a single door to the eastern elevation. Both the northern and eastern elevations are to receive a brick finish at Victoria Lane rear on 1 Hollybank Road, Dublin 9 and all associated site works.

Refusal reason

The proposed retention of the existing storage container and the proposed external cladding and insertion of opes would materially contravene the Z2 zoning objective of the site which is “To protect and/or improve the amenities of residential conservation areas.” The proposed development comprising of a non-conforming use would result in unacceptable negative impacts on the visual amenities of the residential conservation area and would be contrary to Policy BHA9 which aims to protect and enhance the character and appearance of the residential conservation area and its setting, wherever possible. The proposed development would also be contrary to Policy CCUV36 which aims to support uses that would result in the diversification of the evening and night time economy where there is little impact on the amenity of adjoining or adjacent residential uses, and Development Management Standards in that it would, if permitted, adversely impact on the amenity of neighbouring residential uses including No. 1 Hollybank Road and surrounding residential dwellings, and would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

47-48 Hogan Place, Dublin 2, Dublin

47-48 Hogan Place, Dublin 2

Dublin City Council · WEB2929/26

What was proposed

Change of Use of 4 no. Apartments from Residential to Student Accommodation Use.

Refusal reason

The proposed development by itself and by the precedent for which a grant of permission would set would be contrary to the provisions of the City Development Plan 2022-2028 where the core principles of the Dublin Housing Strategy and Policy QHSN38 are to encourage the establishment of sustainable residential communities by ensuring a wide variety of housing typologies and tenures is provided throughout the city in accordance with the Housing Need Demand Assessment (HNDA). It is considered that the applicant has not provided sufficient justification for the provision of student accommodation at this location that differentiates from the existing long term residential use which accommodates for a wide range of housing tenures. As the proposal would not be purpose built student accommodation, the proposal would be contrary to the provisions of Section 15.13.1 of the Development Plan, set an undesirable precedent for similar type development and be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

347 South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 H6OV, Dublin

347 South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 H6OV

Dublin City Council · WEB2927/26

What was proposed

1.The CHANGE OF USE of part of the ground floor of an existing dwelling house to a take away facility with a 4m2 extension to the front of same. 2.New signage to the proposed take away facility. 3.Permission for a single storey rear extension, conversation and alterations to the existing roof space to habitable accommodation to include a new dormer window to the front elevation 4.And associated site development works.

Refusal reasons
  1. The proposed development, by reason of its scale, design and intensity of development, including the proposed front, rear and attic extensions and the provision of a mixed-use development on the site, would constitute an overdevelopment of the site. The proposal would result in the loss of private open space and the provision of residential accommodation with living rooms and bedrooms that fail to meet the minimum floor area standards set out in Quality Housing for Sustainable Communities: Design Guidelines (2007). The proposed development would therefore provide a substandard residential environment for future occupants and would adversely affect the residential amenities of adjoining properties. The proposal is therefore contrary to Section 15.11.1 (Floor Areas), Section 15.11.3 (Private Open Space) and Appendix 18 of the Dublin City Development Plan 2022-2028 and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. 2. The applicant has failed to demonstrate that the proposed takeaway use would not contribute to an excessive concentration of takeaway uses in the area, contrary to Section 15.14.7.3 (Fast Food/Takeaways) of the Dublin City Development Plan 2022-2028. Furthermore, insufficient information has been submitted to demonstrate compliance with Section 15.14.7.4 of said Development Plan relating to noise, odour and ventilation impacts. The Planning Authority is therefore not satisfied that the proposed development would protect the amenities and character of the area and considers that the development would be contrary to the Dublin City Development Plan 2022-2028 and the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Harbour Road (L1320), Loughshinny, Co. Dublin, Dublin

Harbour Road (L1320), Loughshinny, Co. Dublin

Fingal County Council · F26A/0686E

What was proposed

Planning application for (i) two x three bedrooms detached houses facing the road and two x three bedrooms and two x two bedrooms semi detached houses to the rear; (ii) new vehicular access off harbour road (l1320), loughshinny, (iii) internal access road, car parking spaces, boundary fencing, suds, foul drainage, landscaping and all ancillary site development works, at harbour road(l1320), Loughshinny, Fingal, co. Dublin

Refusal reasons
  1. The proposed residential development requires the development of HA – High Amenity zoned lands in order to facilitate the development. Residential development is only permissible on HA zoned lands subject to an applicant demonstrating their compliance with the Councils Rural Settlement Strategy, as set out under section 3.5.15.3 of the Fingal Development Plan 2023-2029. The applicant has failed to submit any documentation demonstrating their compliance with the Councils Rural Settlement Strategy and, as such, the proposed residential development would contravene the HA zoning objective and the Rural Settlement Strategy of the Fingal Development Plan 2023-2029 in its current format. Furthermore, the need to develop on the HA zoned lands is considered unjustified given the ample provision of RS – Residential zoned lands at this location. The proposed development appears to only be able to achieve required separation distances and private open space provisions through the development of HA zoned lands and thus, it is considered the proposal represents overdevelopment of the RS zoned lands at this location. The proposed development would be contrary objectives of the relevant Development Plan, and, therefore, would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. The submitted floor plans for the proposed residential dwellings do not demonstrate full compliance with the internal room area and width requirements for new houses detailed under the Quality Housing for Sustainable Communities Best Practice Guidelines (2007) and the proposed development is considered to represent a substandard form of development which would contravene section 28 Ministerial Guidelines and Objective DMSO19 & sections 14.6.1, 14.6.4 & 14.8.1 of the Fingal Development Plan 2023-2029. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  3. The proposed site layout plan does not demonstrate compliance with the required 2.3m side-to-side separation distances of Objective DMSO26 of the Fingal Development Plan 2023-2029 and these standards are readily achievable on the site given the greenfield nature of the site. The proposed development would be contrary to an objective of the relevant Development Plan and, therefore, would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

33, Finsbury Park, Churchtown, Dublin 14, D14RF78, Dublin

33, Finsbury Park, Churchtown, Dublin 14, D14RF78

Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council · D26B/0442/WEB

What was proposed

The development will consist of amendments to previously granted planning application Reg. Ref.: D25B/0546/WEB to include: the construction of two new 2.2m wide flat roof dormer windows to the front elevation of the main roof at attic level, together with all associated site and development works.

Refusal reason

On the basis of the above considerations, I decide to refuse permission under the terms of Section 34(10)(b) of the Planning and Development Act 2000 (as amended) for the reason set out below. 1. Having regard to character of the existing house and the houses in the vicinity, it is considered that the addition of dormer windows to the roofscape would be incongruous with the established character of the building and the streetscape at this location. In this regard, the proposed development would be contrary to Section 12.3.7.1 of the County Development Plan and would be injurious to the visual amenities of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

43, Leeson Park, Ranelagh, Dublin 6, D06 NR40, Dublin

43, Leeson Park, Ranelagh, Dublin 6, D06 NR40

Dublin City Council · WEB2914/26

What was proposed

PROTECTED STRUCTURE: Balrath Investments ULC intends to apply for permission for development at 43 Leeson Park, Ranelagh, Dublin 6, D06 NR40, a two-storey over garden level, end-of-terrace dwelling with an existing, contemporary part three-storey, part single-storey rear extension, and protected structure, ref no 4356, comprising: (a) removal of the existing non-original single storey garage; (b) removal of non-original internal partitions and finishes; (c) construction of a new single storey extension at garden (lower ground) level to provide a kitchen and living/family room; (d) provision of a partly-roofed terrace and external kitchen to the rear; (e) construction of a new basement beneath the new extension and rear garden, incorporating a central courtyard; (f) formation of a new internal stair to the basement from garden level, under the existing, non-original staircase within the main house; (g) construction of a new single storey garage pavilion to the rear garden, with a new vehicular entrance from Winton Road and internal stairs to the basement level; (h) removal and reuse of a portion of the existing stone boundary wall to form the new garage entrance; (i) formation of a new side entrance at garden level onto Winton Road; (j) removal of an existing window and a portion of the existing cast-iron railings to form the new side entrance with a new solid timber door to match existing front door design; (k) cleaning and repair of the existing stone boundary walls; (l) associated internal alterations, including new and enlarged openings and layout modifications; and (m) all associated ancillary, conservation, essential maintenance, drainage, landscaping and site development works.

Refusal reasons
  1. The proposed development for a basement structure which extends to the entirety of the rear garden is contrary to the requirements as laid out in Appendix 9, Section 3.0 of the Dublin City Development Plan 2022-2018, with regard to its size, proximity to the protected structure and neighbouring boundaries. Furthermore, the applicant has failed to provide sufficient detail in their Basement Impact Assessment to show that due regard has been had in relation to the impacts of such a development of this scale, on the existing building, whereby it is noted that Planning Authority in general, does not support the construction of basements in close proximity to Protected Structures. The proposal is considered overdevelopment of the subject site which would seriously injure the amenity of property in the vicinity, setting an undesirable precedent for similar type development and potentially impacting on the structural integrity of the subject site and adjoining protected structures. The proposal is contrary to Policy BHA2, BHA9, Section 15.15.2.3, Appendix 9 and the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. 2. The applicant has failed to provide sufficient detail in relation to the proposed vehicular entrance from Winton Road and that it will not lead to a traffic hazard. Safe access and egress have not been demonstrated on a c. 5.4 m carriageway with a constrained footpath and planted verge, contrary to Appendix 5, Section 4.3.1. The distance from the proposed gate to the trunk of a large street tree appears to be c. 0.6 m, well below the 3.5 m clearance required by Appendix 5, Section 4.3.2 and Figure 1. The proposal is therefore considered contrary to Appendix 5 of the Dublin City Development Plan, would seriously injure the amenity of property in the vicinity and as such is considered contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

37, Wellington Road, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4, Dublin

37, Wellington Road, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4

Dublin City Council · 5194/26

What was proposed

PROTECTED STRUCTURE: Permission sought for retention of demolition of unstable pedestrian gate pier and section of adjoining street boundary wall; rebuilding of demolished pier and construction of new pier to accommodate a new pair of gates, matching those at the adjoining No. 39 Wellington Road, to provide fit for purpose pedestrian access to 37 Wellington Road; modifications to landscaping in front garden and re-rendering and repairs to remaining section of street boundary wall.

Refusal reasons
  1. The retained 2.75m wide access and associated space within the front garden area has been designed and built in a manner that could lead to its use as a vehicular access and in-curtilage parking. As such, the access would result in the sterilisation / removal of on-street parking in an area of high parking demand which would be contrary to policy SMT25 and section 8.5.7 of the Dublin City Development Plan 2022-2028 which aims to manage on-street parking to serve the needs of the city alongside the needs of residents, visitors, businesses, kerbside activity and accessible parking requirements. The reduced supply of on-street parking would detract from the convenience of road users and the residential amenity of surrounding properties, would be contrary to the stated policy and would set an undesirable precedent for other similar developments on surrounding roads. The proposed development would, therefore, be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. 2. The proposed development, which seeks to regularise the unauthorised demolition of part of the historic boundary wall, railing and gate pier to possible accommodate a vehicular entrance, would give rise to an unacceptable loss of original historic fabric and would cause further serious injury to the historic fabric, legibility and special architectural character of the Protected Structure and its setting. The proposed works would contravene DCC Development Plan 2022-2028 Policies BHA2 (f) and BHA9 and Sections 16.10.18 and 13.4.3 of the Architectural Heritage Protection Guidelines 2011 and would set an undesirable precedent for similar type development. The proposal would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

21, Home Farm Road, Dublin 9, Dublin

21, Home Farm Road, Dublin 9

Dublin City Council · 5193/26

What was proposed

The development will consist of the demolition and reinstatement of an existing rear garage shed and roof, the construction of a new first floor extension to the existing bedroom on the rear return, including new roof-light and solar panels, minor internal alterations and the construction a new dormer roof extension to the existing attic conversion the the rear roof slope, new drainage connections and all ancillary site works.

Refusal reason

Having regard to the scale and positioning of the first-floor extension and its cumulative depth in combination with the existing rear return would have an unacceptable overbearing impact to the adjacent properties and would be visually intrusive, give rise to overlooking and would be out of character with the existing and adjoining dwellings. As such, the proposed development would be contrary to the relevant guidance set out in Appendix 18 of the Dublin City Development Plan 2022-2028, would set an undesirable precedent, and would therefore, be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

12, Hillcrest, Templeogue Rd, Templeogue, D6WKP70, Dublin

12, Hillcrest, Templeogue Rd, Templeogue, D6WKP70

South Dublin County Council · SD26B/0100W

What was proposed

Retention permission for modification to planning permission SD12/0141 for the following; (A) Ground floor apartment known as 12A and (B) First Floor apartment known as 12B as part of the original 2 storey domestic extension to side (west) of property. Permission to extend by 2.0m across the rear of property at ground floor and at first floor.

Refusal reason

Having regard to the plans and particulars lodged with the application on 11/03/2026, by way of Additional Information on 13/07/2026, and by way of Clarification of Additional Information on 01/09/2026, the Planning Authority is not satisfied that the application has been made by a person who has sufficient legal estate or interest in the full extent of lands identified within the redline boundary of land/s subject to this application. Additionally, it is considered that a grant of a permission for the subject proposal may result in the consolidation of unauthorised development at the subject site, which if permitted, would set an undesirable precedent for similar development which in themselves and cumulatively would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

1 Dargle Road, Hollypark, Blackrock, Co. Dublin, A94 XE86, Dublin

1 Dargle Road, Hollypark, Blackrock, Co. Dublin, A94 XE86

Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council · D26A/0320/WEB

What was proposed

a) Demolition of the existing converted garage to the side of the existing dwelling and the subdivision of the site into two b) Construction of a 180 sq.m. two-storey, four-bedroomed dwelling house to include roof mounted solar panels to the side of the existing dwelling c) A 2 sq.m. single storey extension to the front of the existing dwelling adjacent to the existing porch d) The construction of a 14 sq.m. single storey garden room to the rear of the existing dwelling e) Modification of the existing front boundary wall to create two vehicular entrances to serve the new and existing properties; f) All associated landscaping, drainage and site development works.

Refusal reason

Having regard to the design and siting of subject dwelling, which consists of a house in a side garden, it is considered that the proposed development fails to accord with the provisions of Section 12.3.7.5 'Corner, Side Garden sites' of the County Development Plan 2022-2028, by reason of the poor relationship with the neighbouring sites along Holly Park road, resulting in the visually overbearing impacts on the neighbouring sites. Furthermore, it is considered that the scale of the proposed dwelling exceeds the capacity of the site to absorb same, due the location of the substation to the front of the site and the resultant layout and depth of the proposed dwelling resulting in a poor visual relationship. Accordingly, to permit the proposed development would contravene the provisions of the County Development Plan and set an undesirable precedent for similar development in the area. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Lands at No. 59A Terenure Road East, No. 7 Wasdale Grove and Nos. 19-20 Victoria Road, (including existing access laneway between No. 7 Wasdale Grove and No. 19 Victoria Road), Dublin 6, Dublin

Lands at No. 59A Terenure Road East, No. 7 Wasdale Grove and Nos. 19-20 Victoria Road, (including existing access laneway between No. 7 Wasdale Grove and No. 19 Victoria Road), Dublin 6

Dublin City Council · WEB2908/26

What was proposed

(i) removal of existing carpark at No. 59A Terenure Road East, removal of existing single-storey structures, including light-industrial building, car wash unit and adjoining commercial sheds within and adjoining the carpark and removal of single-storey sheds to the rear and side of No. 19 Victoria Road; (ii) demolition of non-original single-storey extensions to the side/rear of No. 7 Wasdale Grove and construction of new single-storey rear extension and new second floor level to this dwelling, with all associated internal/external revisions, to provide a five-bedroom house; (iii) extension, widening and upgrade of existing laneway via Victoria Road to facilitate pedestrian/vehicular access; (iv) construction of a residential development comprising 27 no. houses (1 no. three-bedroom two-storey, 24 no. four-bedroom three-storey & 2 no. five-bedroom three-storey) and 1 no. four-storey apartment block accommodating 19 no. one-bedroom apartments; and, (v) all ancillary works including provision of vehicular parking (including 1 no. accessible visitor parking space), public open space, landscaping, boundary treatments, bin/bicycle stores, provision of foul and surface water drainage, blue/green roofs and all site services, infrastructure and associated works necessary to facilitate the development. Each residential unit will have direct access to private amenity space, in the form of a garden and/or a balcony/terrace. Each apartment will have access to a shared vehicular parking bay of 6 no. spaces and 25 no. houses will be served by on-curtilage vehicular parking spaces, with 2 no. houses served by an adjoining parking bay of 2 no. space. The apartment block is intended to provide independent social housing for older residents (55+ years).

Refusal reasons
  1. 1.Having regard to the siting and proximity of block 8 to the north eastern boundary of the site, with windows and balconies in close proximity to the recreational facilities in Herzog Park, and also the extent of windows on the northern gable elevation of the building, it is considered that the proposed development would seriously injure the amenities of the adjoining properties to the north and east, and may also impede future development potential of the lands to the east. The proposed development would also seriously injure the amenities of the future occupiers of the apartments, due to noise and light related issues from the adjoining recreational uses. The proposed development therefore would be contrary to the Z1 & Z2 zoning objective for the site and to Section 15.13.4 of the Dublin City Development Plan (2022-2028), in relation to backland sites, and therefore contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. 2. Having regard to the length, height and orientation of house block 01, located in the rear garden of number 7 Wasdale Grove, including the proposal for a large dormer roof extension to the existing house at number 7, it is considered that the proposed development would result in an overbearing form of development when viewed from the adjoining property at number 8 Wasdale Grove, and result in overlooking issues form the large dormer window. The proposed development would therefore seriously injure the residential and visual amenities of the adjoining property at number 8 Wasdale Grove, which would be contrary to the Z1 zoning objective and to Appendix 18 Section 5 of the Dublin City Development Plan (2022-2028) in relation to dormer windows, and therefore contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  3. 3. Having regard to the proposal for three storey houses in close proximity to the boundary to the west and also to the rear of properties along Victoria Road, including a number of terraces at first floor level, it is considered that the proposal would result in an overbearing form of development and overlooking issues. In particular, house blocks 02, 03, 04 and 07 may appear overbearing and result in overlooking from the rear terraces at first floor level, when viewed from Cremorne Development and houses on Victoria Road. The proposed development would be contrary to the Z1 and Z2 zoning objectives, would seriously injure the visual and residential amenities of properties in the area, and would be contrary to Policy BHA9 which seeks to protect and enhance the character and appearance of the area and its setting. The proposal would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  4. 4. Having regard to the location and amount of public and communal open space proposed, it is considered that the proposal fails to provide sufficient public open space for a scheme of this size, which would be contrary to section 15.8.6 of the Dublin City Development Plan which sets out a public open space requirement for residential developments of 10% of the overall site area. The proposal would therefore seriously injure the residential amenities of the future occupants of the scheme, which would be contrary to the zoning objective for the site, and the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  5. 5.Having regard to the proposed vehicular access arrangement and associated public realm works, the applicant has failed to demonstrate to the satisfaction of the Planning Authority that the proposed access can achieve the visibility standards set out in DMURS. Furthermore, the proposed access is dependent on alterations to existing on-street parking arrangements on Victoria Road and works within the public realm outside the applicant's control, for which agreement has not been demonstrated. In the absence of satisfactory evidence that the proposed access can be delivered in a safe and effective manner, the Planning Authority is not satisfied that the development would provide for safe vehicular and pedestrian access. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Kiltipper Road, Killinardan, Tallaght, Dublin 24, Dublin

Kiltipper Road, Killinardan, Tallaght, Dublin 24

South Dublin County Council · SD26A/0185W

What was proposed

Permission to construct a new community centre consisting of 3 no. buildings (a) a two-storey administration building of 982.8sq.m, consisting of a café, kitchen, administrative office, group spaces, and ancillary accommodation; (b) a two-storey community building of 773.5sq.m, consisting of group Spaces (with complimentary programming of childcare function), staff facilities and ancillary accommodation; (c) A two-storey exhibition space and Community Space Building of 2178.6sq.m, consisting of a large gallery space, a function room and ancillary accommodation; Externally, the facility will provide play spaces including artificial surfaced pitches, car parking, bike parking, bin storage, a pickup/drop-off area, a farmers market stall area, signage, perimeter boundary treatments and all associated groundworks; Permission to include a new vehicular entrance, a new pedestrian and cycling entrance and link to the dodder valley green way park, all on/adjacent to the existing Kiltipper Road.

Refusal reasons
  1. Having regard to the scale and range of facilities proposed, including group spaces, gallery/exhibition accommodation, function space, childcare programming, café facilities, outdoor recreational facilities and other ancillary accommodation, along with the stated cultural and educational objectives of the development and the stated intention to serve a national, as well as local, catchment, the proposed development cannot be considered only as a 'community centre', which are envisaged in the South Dublin County Development Plan 2022-2028 (CDP) as serving a local catchment, and 'childcare facility', but also constitutes a 'Cultural Use' and 'Place of Worship', all as per the definitions in Appendix 6 of the CDP. All of these uses are open for consideration on RU-zoned lands in Table 12.16 of the CDP, but only in limited circumstances, including in existing premises and in Villages to serve local needs, which do not apply in this instance. Therefore, the proposed development would materially contravene the RU zoning objective for the subject site and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. The proposed development would result in the intensification of use of a substandard rural road network, which is narrow in width, lacks dedicated pedestrian facilities and public lighting. It would therefore endanger public safety by reason of traffic hazard. The traffic and road safety concerns arising from the proposed development cannot be satisfactorily addressed through a request for additional information alone, as the deficiencies identified are considered fundamental to the current proposal and would require a level of infrastructural intervention and design reassessment extending beyond the scope of the current application. Accordingly, the proposed development, in its current form, would be contrary to the provisions of the South Dublin County Development Plan 2022-2028, in particular SM5 Objective 4, which seeks: 'To prioritise safety on rural roads and junctions, while considering the protection of biodiversity, green infrastructure and rural character present in roadside trees, hedgerows and banks, and so on'. The proposed development would, therefore, be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Ballinascorney Golf Club, Oldfield, Kilmashogue Lane, Rathfarnham, Dublin 16, Dublin

Ballinascorney Golf Club, Oldfield, Kilmashogue Lane, Rathfarnham, Dublin 16

Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council · D26A/0576/WEB

What was proposed

a) the construction of a single storey detached dwelling; b) closure of an existing access and its replacement with replenishment planting; (c) a new vehicle entrance from the public roadway and; c) a new waste water treatment system with a percolation area. This is all together with all associated site works including new landscaping.

Refusal reason

RECOMMENDATION It is recommended that Planning Permission be REFUSED for the following reason: 1.The applicant has not demonstrated, to the satisfaction of the Planning Authority, a genuine need to reside in proximity to their employment or a genuine need for an additional dwelling in the rural area. While it is acknowledged that the applicant's stated employment relates to the management and operation of Ballinascorney Golf Club, insufficient information and supporting documentary evidence have been submitted to establish a clear and compelling justification for a one-off dwelling at this location. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to Policy Objective PHP23 - Management of One-off Housing and Section 12.3.10 - One-Off Housing in the Countryside of the Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Development Plan 2022-2028, as well as the stated zoning objective 'To protect and improve rural amenity and to provide for the development of agriculture', and would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Cielito, Blackglen Road, Sandyford, Dublin 18, Dublin

Cielito, Blackglen Road, Sandyford, Dublin 18

Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council · D14A/0090/E3

What was proposed

The division of an existing site to construct 1 number 3 bedroom dormer bungalow with rooflights facing north and south, balcony facing north, removal of existing septic tank, modifications to entrance gates and pillars to the front, reconstruction of new 2.4m stone boundary wall set back to accommodate new 2m wide footpath adjacent to existing Blackglen Road and all associated site works.

Refusal reason

RECOMMENDATION Having regard to the above, I recommend that pursuant to Section 42(4) of the Planning and Development Act 2000, as amended, the Extension of Duration of Permission be refused for the following reason: 1. The Planning Authority notes that the duration of the permission has been extended twice previously. Therefore, the criteria set under Section 42(4) of the Planning and Development Act 2000 are not met.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Concrete Pumping Ltd, Greenhills Road, Walkinstown, Dublin 12, Dublin

Concrete Pumping Ltd, Greenhills Road, Walkinstown, Dublin 12

South Dublin County Council · SD26A/0184W

What was proposed

(1) Demolition of all existing industrial and warehouse structures on site (579.1 sq.m) and associated site clearance works; (2) Construction of part 6, part 7, part 10 storey over basement mixed use block providing 99 no. apartments, comprising 49 no. one-bed units and 50 no. two-bed units, with balconies on all elevations; (3) Provision of a commercial unit (148.2sqm) fronting onto Greenhills Road at ground floor level along with a designated set down area/loading bay; (4) Provision of 87.2 sq.m of designated indoor residential amenity space at the ground floor level; (5) Provision of 1,127 sq.m of Communal Open Space to the rear of the site; (6) An access ramp to facilitate vehicular access to the basement car park which will provide 38 no. car parking spaces; A further 2 no. accessible car parking spaces are provided at ground level, resulting in a total of 40 no car parking spaces; (7) A total of 204 no. bicycle parking spaces (comprising 150 no. long stay and 54 no. short stay) at ground and basement level; (8) Provision of 68m of footpath along the Greenhills Road frontage, and a pedestrian crossing across the Greenhills Road; (9) All enabling and associated site development and works including landscaping, footpaths, boundary treatments, lighting, water and utility services and connections, bin stores, plant and all ancillary development and works above and below ground.

Refusal reasons
  1. Notwithstanding the location of the site relative to existing and planned public transport provision, it is considered that justification has not been demonstrated for the proposed density of 291dph, which would substantially exceed the maximum density range of 50-250dph for a ‘City - Urban Neighbourhoods’ area, as defined within the 2024 Compact Settlements Guidelines. Having regard to same, it is the opinion of the Planning Authority that the development as proposed would not accord with the provisions of QDP8 High Quality Design – Building Height and Density Guide (BHDG) Objectives 1 and 2 of the 2022-2028 CDP. It is considered that the proposed density together with insufficient public open space, insufficient green space factor score, insufficient play spaces, poor access to sunlight performance in terms of 24% of units failing to achieve the minimum 1.5hr sunlight to a habitable room as recommended in BRE 209:2022 and surface water attenuation, are in combination indicative of overdevelopment of the subject site which would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. The proposal has not adequately demonstrated to the satisfaction of the Planning Authority that the subject development would not result in adverse impacts on the residential amenity of units within the subject scheme by way of potential inward noise and odour, and that the proposed development of this site would not give rise to isolated piecemeal pockets of residential development that are disconnected from shops, amenities and/or other residences. It is therefore considered that the proposed development has not demonstrated compliance with the criteria of Section 12.9.1 Regeneration Zone of the 2022-2028 CDP. The proposal, if permitted, would set an undesirable precedent for other similar developments, which would in themselves and cumulatively, be harmful to proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

99 St. Fintan's Park, Deansgrange, Co. Dublin, A94WV05, Dublin

99 St. Fintan's Park, Deansgrange, Co. Dublin, A94WV05

Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council · D26A/0573/WEB

What was proposed

1) Subdivision of the site at 99 St. Fintan’s Park to create 2 separate sites (99 and 99A St. Fintan’s Park). 2) The Construction of a new 2-storey 2 bedroom house (99A St. Fintan’s Park to be 78.8sq.m.) attached at the western gable to 99 St Fintan’s Park with (a) a new vehicular entrance and space for 1 no. car park to serve 99 St. Fintan’s Park and pedestrian entrance to serve 99A St. Fintan’s Park (b) a rooflight to front of house (c) private open space to rear and front of house (d) all hard and soft landscaping, boundary treatments and associated site works and services. 3) Alterations to 99 St. Fintan’s Park to include (a) alterations to existing vehicular entrance, landscaping and boundary treatments, site works and services (b) alterations to fenestration to western gable (c) repositioning of front door from western gable to front elevation.

Refusal reason

I recommend that a decision to REFUSE PERMISSION be made under the Planning and Development Act 2000 (as amended) for the following reasons:- Having regard to the nature of the dwelling which provides for an independent two bedroom dwelling and to the inadequate quantum of private open space proposed, the Planning Authority considers that the proposed development fails to accord to Section 12.8.3.3 Private Open Space of the County Development Plan 2022-2028 and SPPR 2 of the Sustainable Residential Developments and Compact Settlement Guidelines by reason of the 18.5 sq.m. of private amenity space proposed. Furthermore, additional concerns arise in respect of the quality of the rear amenity space proposed, by reason of its orientation, as well as the reduction in usable open space to the front of the dwelling due to the siting of the bin stores, bike storage areas and general access routes within same. Accordingly, to permit the proposed development would set an undesirable precedent for similar development in the area. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

8-9 Grant's Row (also accessible from 11A Grattan Street), Dublin 2, Dublin

8-9 Grant's Row (also accessible from 11A Grattan Street), Dublin 2

Dublin City Council · WEB2878/26

What was proposed

CHANGE OF USE i) change of use of building from office to tourist hostel with all associated revisions to the internal layout and external elevations; (ii) provision of signage above the building entrance via Grant’s Row; (iii) demolition of existing single-storey extension to the rear and construction of a new single-storey extension to the rear to accommodate new hostel facilities and new bike and bin stores; (iv) provision of set-down parking space, bicycle parking area and enclosed outdoor seating area to the front of the building via Grant’s Row; and (v) all associated works, including boundary treatments, landscaping, infrastructure and drainage necessary to facilitate the development.

Refusal reasons
  1. Having regard to the location of the site within a transitional zone between Grants Row and Grattan Street and the adjoining residential conservation area to the north and north-east, the Planning Authority considers that the applicant has not satisfactorily demonstrated that the proposed development would not result in an overconcentration of tourist accommodation in the immediate area. Such overconcentration would result in an unacceptable intensification of activity, including increased night-time activity, noise and disturbance, within the adjoining residential area, to the serious detriment of the residential amenities of that area, and would fail to provide an appropriate transition in land use between the two areas. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to Policy CEE28 (Visitor Accommodation), Section 15.14.2 (Bed and Breakfast/Guesthouses) and Section 14.6 (Transitional Zone Areas) of the Dublin City Development Plan 2022-2028 and would, therefore, be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. 2. The proposed development fails to provide for adequate dining, kitchen and laundry facilities to cater for a Tourist Hostel of this scale. The proposed development would therefore result in over intensification of this site which would be seriously injurious to the residential amenities of the area and would be contrary to Section 15.14.2 (Bed and Breakfast/Guesthouses) of the Dublin City Development Plan 2022-2028. The proposal would create a precedent for similar type development and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet