Refusal decisions · 28 Sep–4 Oct 2026

60Refusals
48Substantive reasons
0Verification only
1Document not published
4Portal unavailable
7Manual review

What this means

Applications were most often refused because the proposal did not fit its site or surroundings, conflicted with zoning or rural-housing policy, created access or road-safety problems, harmed the amenity of neighbouring homes or lacked enough technical evidence to demonstrate its impacts were acceptable.

48 of 60 records carry official reason text

101 published statements, 2.1 per analysed application

24 refused on more than one ground, up to 11

Most common pairs

  1. 20 Design + Zoning/policy
  2. 19 Design + Transport/access
  3. 17 Design + Residential amenity

All ten refusal themes

Applications · statements
  1. 01 Design, scale, character or visual impact 38
  2. 02 Zoning, land use, settlement policy or rural housing need 23
  3. 03 Traffic, access, parking or road safety 21
  4. 04 Residential amenity, privacy, light or noise 20
  5. 05 Missing or insufficient evidence, surveys or technical detail 13
  6. 06 Built heritage or archaeology 13
  7. 07 Wastewater, effluent, groundwater or public health 11
  8. 08 Unauthorised development, retention or procedural history 10
  9. 09 Ecology, habitats or Natura impacts 9
  10. 10 Surface-water drainage or flood risk 5

Refusal decisions · 28 Sep–4 Oct 2026

50 of 60 cards shown · 48 case links · 0 linked projects

Refused

Lynn Road, Mullingar, Co. Westmeath, Westmeath

Lynn Road, Mullingar, Co. Westmeath

Westmeath County Council · 2660422

What was proposed

to construct 3 no. (100sqm) agricultural sheep sheds, with solar panels located on the roof of each structure (300sqm total) and all associated site works

Refusal reasons

Reasons under review. View the official case.

Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Pishanagh, Walderstown, Co Westmeath, Westmeath

Pishanagh, Walderstown, Co Westmeath

Westmeath County Council · 2660420

What was proposed

RETENTION planning permission is for existing vehicle storage and maintenance shed, roadway and entrance, pump house, low garden wall and for the temporary retention of storage container and planning permission is sought for the adjustment of road boundary hedge and for the instillation of septic tank and percolation area and the change of use of small store to toilet and all ancillary works

Refusal reasons
  1. The development subject to retention comprises a substantial standalone vehicular storage and maintenance building which, by reason of its scale, height, form and overall character, does not present as a subordinate domestic garage, shed or outbuilding and is not ancillary to an established dwelling on the site. The development therefore constitutes an inappropriate form of development in this rural location, is inconsistent with the established rural residential character of the area, and materially conflicts with County Policy Objective CPO 16.34 of the Westmeath County Development Plan 2021-2027. The development would, therefore, be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. Having regard to the scale, layout, design, siting and visual appearance of the development subject to retention, the Planning Authority considers that the development fails to integrate satisfactorily into its rural setting and does not represent an appropriate design response to the established character and pattern of development in the surrounding area. By reason of its scale, height, massing and form, the development constitutes an unduly prominent and incongruous feature within the rural landscape and seriously detracts from the visual amenities and rural character of the area. Furthermore, the development has not been sensitively designed so as to minimise its visual impact on the landscape. The development is therefore contrary to County Policy Objective CPO 13.6 of the Westmeath County Development Plan 2021-2027, which requires that development be sensitively designed so as to minimise its visual impact on the landscape, nature conservation, archaeology and groundwater quality, and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Coolmuckbane, Monaghan, Co Monaghan, Monaghan

Coolmuckbane, Monaghan, Co Monaghan

Monaghan County Council · 2660030

What was proposed

permission for the construction of a storey and a half dwelling and single storey domestic garage, new sewage treatment system, relocation of existing treatment system for existing neighbouring dwelling, connection to group water scheme, new entrance, entrance walls piers, and all ancillary site works. Significant further information received relates to relocation of dwelling entrance, minor adjustments to the plans and elevations, Flood risk assessment, traffic report, Soil characterisation, and site layout plan

Refusal reasons

Reasons not yet available here. View the official case.

Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Quay St, Westport, Co. Mayo, Mayo

Quay St, Westport, Co. Mayo

Mayo County Council · 2660636

What was proposed

The development will consist of the construction of a residential development comprising 4 no. own-door residential units including 2 no. 3-bedroom duplex apartments, 1 no. 2-bedroom apartment and 1 no. studio apartment together with connection to public services and all ancillary site works.

Refusal reasons
  1. The proposed development is located close to adjoining boundaries, and by virtue of its height, massing, along with the proposed installation of windows overlooking adjoining residential properties to the east, would adversely impact the visual amenity of the area and the residential amenity of neighbouring dwellings. It is considered that the proposed development would seriously injure the visual and residential amenity of the area, would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area and would depreciate the value of property in the vicinity. The proposed development is, therefore, contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. The proposed development consisting of 4 apartment units on a site area of 0.021ha represents an excessively high-density development with a density of 190 dph. Therefore, it is considered that the proposed development would give rise to over development of the site and would be contrary to Section 3.0 of Sustainable Residential Development and Compact Settlements Guidelines for Planning Authorities (2024) issued under Section 28 of the Planning and Development Act, 2020 as amended, and also the residential density standards within Section 4.4 of Volume 2 of the Mayo County Development Plan 2022 - 2028. or Therefore, it is considered that, if granted, the development would constitute over development of the site which would impact negatively on the amenity and character of the area and would depreciate the value of property on the area. The proposed development would, therefore, be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. g in
  3. The proposed development is located at Quay Street on the fringe of Westport Architectural nn Conservation Area (ACA) at a prominent town centre location with a strong traditional a streetscape. Given its location at a prominent siting on approach to the historical town core Pl and fringe of the ACA, it is considered that the proposed development, by reason of its scale and design, would have a significant negative impact on the character, setting and o appreciation of this streetscape and would set an undesirable precedent for similar type ay developments in the town. Therefore, the proposed development, if granted, would interfere M with the character of the streetscape at this location which would depreciate the value of the properties in the vicinity and be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

The Green, Annagassan, Co Louth, Louth

The Green, Annagassan, Co Louth

Louth County Council · 2660556

What was proposed

Permission for construction of a two storey house and associated site works

Refusal reasons
  1. Having regard to the location of the proposed development in close proximity to, and with hydrological connectivity to, Dundalk Bay SAC (Site Code: 000455) and Dundalk Bay SPA (Site Code: 004026), together with the location of the site within a floodplain and its potential susceptibility to coastal erosion, the Planning Authority considers that pathways exist by which the proposed development could adversely affect the qualifying interests and conservation objectives of these European sites. Applying the precautionary principle, and in the absence of a project-specific Natura Impact Statement (NIS) containing sufficient scientific information to enable the Planning Authority to undertake a Stage 2 Appropriate Assessment, the Planning Authority cannot ascertain, beyond reasonable scientific doubt, that the proposed development, either individually or in combination with other plans or projects, would not adversely affect the integrity of the European sites concerned. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to Policy Objective NBG 6 of the Louth County Development Plan 2021-2027, as varied, and the requirements of Article 6(3) of the Habitats Directive and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. The proposed development would extend substantially onto unzoned lands within Dundalk Bay SPA, beyond those lands identified as ‘A1 Existing Residential’ in the Louth County Development Plan 2021–2027, as varied. Having regard to the purpose of the land-use zoning framework as set out in Section 13.21.1 of the Louth County Development Plan 2021–2027, as varied, the environmentally sensitive nature of the unzoned lands and their location within Dundalk Bay SPA, it is considered that the principle of extending the proposed development onto these lands is unacceptable. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to Section 13.21.1 of the Louth County Development Plan 2021–2027, as varied and to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  3. The applicant has failed to demonstrate that the proposed vehicular entrance can provide adequate, clear and unobstructed sightlines in accordance with Section 13.16.17 of the Louth County Development Plan 2021–2027, as varied, and the requirements of the Design Manual for Urban Roads and Streets (DMURS), where applicable. In the absence of demonstrated visibility splays, the Planning Authority is not satisfied that the proposed entrance would facilitate the safe movement of vehicles entering and exiting the site, having regard also to pedestrians, cyclists and other vulnerable road users. The proposed development would therefore endanger public safety by reason of traffic hazard and would be contrary to Section 13.16.17 of the Louth County Development Plan 2021–2027, as varied, DMURS and the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. L o u t h C C, !
  4. The proposed development constitutes a highly vulnerable residential use within an area identified as being at risk of coastal flooding. The submitted Flood Risk Assessment is inconsistent with the development for which permission is sought and fails to adequately demonstrate an appropriate Finished Floor Level referenced to Malin Head Ordnance Datum, having regard to the identified 0.5% AEP coastal flood level, appropriate freeboard and allowance for climate change. The Planning Authority is therefore not satisfied that the proposed development would avoid an unacceptable risk of flooding or that flood risk can be appropriately managed. Accordingly, the proposed development would be contrary to Policy Objectives IU 26 and IU 27 of the Louth County Development Plan 2021–2027 (as varied), the principles of The Planning System and Flood Risk Management – Guidelines for Planning Authorities (2009), and the proper planning and sustainable development of the area
  5. The proposed development is located within 100 metres of the coastline in an area subject to known coastal erosion. In the absence of a site-specific Coastal Erosion Assessment Report, the applicant has failed to demonstrate that the site is suitable for the proposed residential development having regard to existing and future coastal erosion risk, or that the development would not necessitate coastal protection works which could adversely affect the natural coastal defences and environmentally sensitive lands of Dundalk Bay. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to Policy Objectives ENV 50 and ENV 52 of the Louth County Development Plan 2021–2027, as varied, and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. L o u t h C C, !
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Templetown, Carlingford, Co.Louth, Louth

Templetown, Carlingford, Co.Louth

Louth County Council · 26103

What was proposed

Retention permission for a storage shed and associated site development works.

Refusal reasons

Reasons under review. View the official case.

Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Ticknevin, Carbury, County Kildare, Kildare

Ticknevin, Carbury, County Kildare

Kildare County Council · 2660913

What was proposed

single storey + storey and a half dwelling, site entrance, effluent treatment plant, landscaping and all associated site development works.

Refusal reasons
  1. Policy HO P26 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied) seeks to “Sensitively consider the capacity of the receiving environment to absorb further development of the nature proposed through the application of Kildare County Council’s ‘Single Rural Dwelling Density’ Toolkit (see Appendix 11)” and “Examine and consider the extent and density of existing development in the area”. Having regard to the level of existing development in the wider area it is considered that the proposed development would result in the further suburbanisation of the receiving environment and would erode the rural character of the immediate area and therefore would be contrary to the provisions of HOP26 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied) and to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. Objective HO O59 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied) seeks to “Carefully manage Single Rural Dwelling Densities to ensure that the density of one-off housing does not exceed 30 units per square kilometre, unless the Applicant is actively engaged in agriculture, or an occupation that is heavily dependent on the land and building on their own landholding.” In conjunction with the level of existing development in the vicinity which is measured at over 30 units per square kilometre, it is considered that the proposed development would exacerbate an excessive density of development in this rural area, would contribute to the increasing suburbanisation of the area. The proposed development would materially contravene Objective HO O59 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied) and would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  3. Policy HO P12 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied) seeks to ensure that the siting and design of any proposed dwelling shall integrate appropriately with its physical surroundings. The design of all new dwellings in rural areas should respond sensitively to the characteristics of the receiving environment. New dwellings should blend into and not dominate the local landscape. Proposals must also comply with Appendix 4 Rural House Design Guide and Chapter 15 Development Management Standards. It is considered that the proposed development, by way of the proposed overly complicated design and its scale, would not sensitively integrate with the established pattern of development in the rural area and the environment and would be contrary to Policy HO P12 and Appendix 4 Rural House Design Guide of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied) and would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Sherlockstown, Sallins, Co. Kildare, Kildare

Sherlockstown, Sallins, Co. Kildare

Kildare County Council · 2660912

What was proposed

(A) new detached single storey dwelling house, (b) new on-site domestic wastewater treatment system, (c) upgraded access road extending to new recessed vehicular entrance, (d) landscaping about the subject site and all associated development works on lands

Refusal reasons
  1. Policy HO P26 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied) seeks to sensitively consider the capacity of the receiving environment to absorb further development. It is considered that the proposed development, in conjunction with the level of existing and permitted development in the vicinity would further exacerbate an excessive density of development in this rural area and would contribute to the increasing suburbanisation of the area. Having regard to the foregoing and the intended interpretation of the above Policy, it is considered that the proposed development would contravene policy HO P26 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023- 2029 (as varied) and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. It is the policy of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied) under HO P12 to ensure that the siting and design of any proposed dwelling integrates appropriately with its physical surroundings whilst respecting the character of the receiving environment. The proposed site, being carved out a larger field and requiring more than one boundary, and the proposed upgrading of an existing substandard trackway to gain access, all of which would be compounded by the siting of the dwelling setback approximately 400m from the local road, does not accord with Section 2.4 of Appendix 4 of the Rural House Design Guide of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied). Having regard to the foregoing, the proposed development contravenes Policy HO P12 and Appendix 4 of the Rural House Design Guide, which would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  3. Notwithstanding the documents submitted pertaining to the improvement works of the section of private/shared road serving the proposed site, the Planning Authority is not satisfied that the access infrastructure is sufficient for residential use. A grant of permission would set an undesirable precedent for additional dwellings to utilise the sub-standard single access track as part of a future application. Having regard to the submitted information, the Planning Authority is not satisfied that the access track can accommodate additional traffic pressures, while also being contrary to the standards outlined in Section 15.7.6 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied), as well as to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Mullaghreelan, Kilkea, Co. Kildare, Kildare

Mullaghreelan, Kilkea, Co. Kildare

Kildare County Council · 2561284

What was proposed

the construction of a single storey dwelling, a new entrance, septic tank & percolation area, a bored well and all associated site works

Refusal reasons
  1. The works required to provide for the access/egress point to the site would require the removal and/or disturbance of a significant amount of mature vegetation including trees and hedgerows, and may require the removal of additional trees and hedgerow to achieve the indicated sightlines which has not been depicted on the submitted documentation. A site in close proximity to the Kilkea Demesne where the loss of trees on the approach to the Demesne would have a significant negative impact on the rural character at this location, would be contrary to Objective HO 051, HO O52 and BI O26 in the Kildare County Development Plan 2023–2029 (as varied) which seeks to prevent the removal of hedgerows to facilitate development in the first instance. To permit the removal of existing trees and hedgerows on site in the absence of detailed assessment of same, in the context of green infrastructure, natural heritage, biodiversity/ecology, would be contrary to the provisions of Objective HO 051, HO O52 and BI O26, Section 12.9.1 and Appendix 4 Rural House Design Guide of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023–2029 (as varied) and would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. Policy HO P11 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 seeks to facilitate proposals for dwellings in the countryside outside of settlements in accordance with the National Planning Framework Policy NPO 19 in conjunction with the rural housing policy zone map and accompanying Schedule of Category of Applicant and Local Need Criteria. To establish a genuine local housing need, the Applicant was assessed against Category B of Zone 2 as set out in Table 3.4 of the Plan. Based on the information submitted, the Applicant has not provided sufficient documentary evidence demonstrating that she has grown up and spent a substantial period of her life in the rural area in which it is proposed to build. Accordingly, the proposed development would be contrary to policy HO P11 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023- 2029 and to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. Note to Applicant: The Applicant is advised that there may be a more appropriate site available for the proposed development within the undefined residential cluster of Ballyroe, located close to the Applicant’s home address.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Bollum Lane, Rush, Co. Dublin., Dublin

Bollum Lane, Rush, Co. Dublin.

Fingal County Council · F26A/0726E

What was proposed

For the construction of 3no. three bedroom with study two storey detached dwellings along with new boundary treatments associated landscaping and all other ancillary site development works at Bollum Lane, Rush, Co. Dublin.

Refusal reasons
  1. The proposed development constitutes overdevelopment of a constrained site given its linear nature and distance from the boundaries of the proposed houses. The development as proposed is of an incongruous design, form and layout on a restricted site which is out of character with the surrounding pattern of development and would be contrary to Table 14.4 and Objectives SPQHO42 & SPQHO39 of the Fingal Development 2023-2029 and the TC – Town and District Centre zoning of the subject site. To permit the development as proposed would prejudice development at the adjacent site to the east, and would set an undesirable precedent for similar substandard development in this location and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. Due to substandard access for vehicles and lack of car parking in line with Development Plan requirements the proposed development would endanger public safety by reason of serious traffic hazard. The development is therefore contrary to Objective DMSO118 of the Fingal Development Plan 2023-2029, and contrary to the proper and sustainable development of the area.
  3. The applicant has provided insufficient information to demonstrate adequate proposals regarding foul sewer and surface water drainage. The application submission has therefore failed to demonstrate that the proposed development would not be prejudicial to public health and the amenity of the surrounding area. The development, as proposed, is therefore contrary to Objectives DMSO197 and DMSO203 of the Fingal Development Plan, and contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

The Bus Bar, 98 Strand Street, Skerries, Co. Dublin, K34 V300, Dublin

The Bus Bar, 98 Strand Street, Skerries, Co. Dublin, K34 V300

Fingal County Council · F26A/0518E

What was proposed

Permission for a retractable canopy enclosure of the front terrace of the existing pub. The premises are located within an Architectural Conservation Area. Additional Information Received 08/09/2026

Refusal reason

The proposed development of a fixed framed steel structure to the front elevation of the existing building, is considered to read and function as a permanent single storey extension which is considered to be an incongruous addition to the front elevation of the building and in turn the local streetscape of Strand Street, and would have a significant detrimental impact on the amenities of the Skerries ACA. The proposed development would therefore contravene Policies HCAP14, HCAP15 and Objective HCAO24 of the Fingal Development Plan 2023-2029. The proposed development would set an undesirable precedent if granted, and for the above reason would be considered contrary to the proper and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

28, Saint Laurence's Park, Stillorgan, Co. Dublin, A94R659, Dublin

28, Saint Laurence's Park, Stillorgan, Co. Dublin, A94R659

Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council · D26A/0597/WEB

What was proposed

The proposed development consists of the subdivision of the existing site curtilage and the construction of a new part single storey / part two storey two bedroom dwelling with hipped roof to the side garden of the existing dwelling (no. 28), together with: 1 no. new vehicular entrance incorporating 2 no. new gate piers (no gates proposed) involving partial removal of the existing front boundary wall, serving 1 no. off-street car parking space; 1 no. new pedestrian entrance; covered bicycle storage and bin storage; new boundary treatments and planting to the side of and within the site; green roof, rainwater harvesting and rain garden sustainable drainage measures; and new connections to the public foul and surface water drainage networks and all other services and all associated site development and ancillary works.The development also includes works to the existing dwelling no. 28 comprising new external wall insulation and rendered finish to the front and rear elevations, the blocking up of 2 no. existing windows to the side (gable) elevation, and a new unifying projecting entrance canopy on support columns to match the neighbouring properties, together with landscaping, site works and all associated ancillary works.

Refusal reason

REASONS Pursuant to the Planning and Development Acts 2000, (as amended), it is hereby recommended, for the reason set out in the First Schedule hereto, to REFUSE PERMISSION for proposed dwelling for the following reasons: 1. Having regard to the zoning of the site 'A', its constrained size and corner site nature, the proposed development would result in inadequate and substandard private open space provision for both the proposed dwelling and the existing dwelling, resulting in an overdevelopment of the site. In particular, the proposed private open space for new dwelling is significantly deficient in terms of quality, privacy and functionality and fails to provide a meaningful quantum of usable rear garden space, thereby creating a substandard residential environment. The proposal would therefore constitute overdevelopment, would adversely affect residential amenity, and would be contrary to Sections 12.3.7.5 and 12.3.7.7 of the Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Development Plan 2022-2028, SPPR 2 of the Sustainable Residential Development and Compact Settlements Guidelines for Planning Authorities (2024), and the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.[

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

The Rezz Hotel, 54/55 McCurtain Street, Cork City (Rooftop Level), Cork

The Rezz Hotel, 54/55 McCurtain Street, Cork City (Rooftop Level)

Cork City Council · 26/44958

What was proposed

Permission is sought for the installation of a telecommunications development at rooftop level comprising: the installation of 7 No. panel antennas, 2 No. GPS antennas, 2 No. equipment cabinets, 2 No. AC distribution boards mounted on steel support frames, the installation of associated radio equipment, remote radio units (RRUs), mounted brackets, dishes, ballast mounts, the relocation of an existing satellite dish ballast assembly, 2 No. rooftop step-over units together with all associated site development works necessary to provide for high-speed wireless data and broadband services.

Refusal reasons
  1. The subject site is situated in a highly sensitive receiving environment, being located on the rooftop of an 8-storey tall building located within the MacCurtain Street Architectural Conservation Area (ACA). The site is visually prominent and is deemed not to be an appropriate location for the provision of telecommunications given the extent and scale of that proposed in this instance. The proposed telecommunications infrastructure, if permitted, would be highly visible from the public realm, would be visually incongruous and result in a high concentration of telecommunications equipment/ apparatus in this visually prominent location. The proposed development by reason of its location, scale, height and design would seriously injure the visual amenities of the area, would be contrary to section 11.256 of the Cork City Development Plan 2022-2028 (as varied) and the proper planning and sustainable development of the area
  2. The installation of telecommunications antennae and other plant as proposed at this location would result in adverse impacts on the architectural heritage and special character of the MacCurtain Street Architectural Conservation Area and the character and setting of Local Landmark Building Trinty Presbyterian Church, a Protected Structure (Ref. PS425) as per Volume 3 of the Cork City Development Plan 2022-2028 (as varied), and would therefore be contrary to Strategic Objective 7 and Objectives 8.17, 8.19 and 8.23 of the Cork City Development Plan 2022-2028 (as varied) and would be contrary to proper planning and sustainable development of the area
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Kerry Road, Coolflugh, Tower, Blarney, Cork, T23YD34, Cork

Kerry Road, Coolflugh, Tower, Blarney, Cork, T23YD34

Cork City Council · 26/44957

What was proposed

Permission for the following works: (A) Alterations to an existing detached garage, including: (I) Increase in ridge height by 2.05m and new pitched roof; (II) Addition of a second floor within the existing garage; (III) Elevational alterations to the southern elevation by extension of the building's external footprint by 6.86sqm at this elevation; (IV) Elevational alterations to the eastern elevation by extension of the building's external footprint by 27.0 sqm at this elevation; (V) Fenestration alterations to the western and northern elevations; (B) Construction of a new two-storey extension (including new fenestration) to the southern and eastern garage elevations, changing its use from garage to two-bed dwelling house (increasing gross floor space from 43.8 sqm to 97.1 sqm); and (C) Associated site works; to the rear of the existing property.

Refusal reason

The proposed development by reason of its siting, scale, height and proximity to the existing dwelling, and severance of the established curtilage associated with the existing dwelling, would result in unacceptable overbearance impacts, an inadequate standard of private open space for the existing dwelling, and a form of backland development that would fail to integrate coherently with the established pattern of development in the area, setting an undesirable precedent for the area and would seriously injure the residential amenities of adjacent properties. The proposal would therefore be contrary to Objectives 3.5 and 11.3 of the Cork City Development Plan 2022-2028, as Varied and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

60 Saint Patrick's Street, Cork, T12XT57, Cork

60 Saint Patrick's Street, Cork, T12XT57

Cork City Council · 26/44954

What was proposed

Permission for retention for illuminated signage to existing shopfront to existing retail premises on ground floor.

Refusal reason

Due to the adverse impacts on the character of 60 St Patrick’s Street, which is recorded on the National Inventory of Architectural Heritage (Reg. 20513119) and is located in the Oliver Plunkett Street Architectural Conservation Area (ACA), the existing development fails to adhere to the policies and objectives of the Cork City Development Plan 2022-2028, namely; Strategic Objective 7, Objective 8.22, Objective 8.23, Section 11.193 and Section 11.195. The design and materials of the existing signage fail to complement or respect the ACA and detract from its architectural heritage and special character. The existing development also fails to have regard to the Architectural Heritage Protection, Guidelines for Planning Authorities (Department of Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht, 2011) and if permitted, would set an undesirable precedent for similar type of development and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

No. 2 Westbourne Terrace, Quinsborough Road, Bray, Co. Wicklow, A98 VF59, Wicklow

No. 2 Westbourne Terrace, Quinsborough Road, Bray, Co. Wicklow, A98 VF59

Wicklow County Council · 2660748

What was proposed

(1) Removal of existing rear garden storage building along the east boundary; (2) Converting the existing first and second floors into two studio apartments; (3) Construction of a new three-storey rear extension comprising of three one-bedroom apartments on the ground, first and second floor levels (totalling two studio apartments and three one-bedroom apartments across the development); (4) Provision of all associated site works, including bicycle parking and bin storage facilities at ground floor level.

Refusal reason

Having regard to: a) The inadequate separation distances between the windows serving the proposed apartments within the site itself and between the windows serving the upper floor one-bedroom units and the existing property to the north; b) The lack of provision of private amenity space serving 2 apartments coupled with the poor quality of the private open space serving the remaining three units noting their north-facing aspect, proximity to existing opposing windows and in the case of the ground floor unit, directly addressing the rear service area of the adjoining hotel. c) The overall poor design and lack of detail submitted to demonstrate that the proposed apartments would receive adequate levels of sunlight and daylight; d) The location of the bin store within the courtyard of the proposed development resulting in noise and odour nuisance in this restricted space for the proposed residential units, e) The proposed density of the development at 217 units per hectare, which significantly exceeds the maximum density considered appropriate for this location and; f) The lack of detail submitted outlining the relationship between the proposed extension and adjoining properties to demonstrate that the proposal would not appear overbearing or result in an unacceptable level of increased overlooking or increased overshadowing of these adjoining properties; It is considered that the proposed development would result in the overdevelopment of the site and in a haphazard and substandard form of residential development which would be contrary to Objectives CPO 6.3, CPO 6.4 and CPO 6.16 of the 2022-2028 County Development Plan which seek the highest possible standard of living for future occupants and the highest quality of layout and design for new residential developments, while protecting the existing amenity of an area. The proposed development if granted would set an undesirable precedent for similar type development in this town centre area and would therefore be contrary to proper planning and sustainable development.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Ballyteige, Ballycanew, Wexford

Ballyteige, Ballycanew

Wexford County Council · 20261078W

What was proposed

Permission for retention of (1) an existing domestic storage and home office building of 38.5 sq.m (414.41 sq.ft) and (2) for the change of use of an existing agricultural buildings to short-term letting accommodation of 39.5 sq.m (425.17 sq.ft) adjoining an existing 1930 tool shed and (3) all associated site development works

Refusal reason

The proposed change of use from agricultural building to short-term letting would be contrary to Section 7.7.5 and Objective TM49 of Volume 1 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028 which seeks to protect the County's existing housing stock from any proposal that would undermine the supply of housing within the county. The proposed change of use of agricultural shed to short-term letting in an unserviced rural area remote from dedicated services, including a public footpath and public lighting, would also be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Ballycourcy More, Enniscorthy Rural, Wexford

Ballycourcy More, Enniscorthy Rural

Wexford County Council · 20261068W

What was proposed

Permission to construct a fully serviced two-storey dwelling house with associated site works

Refusal reason

The site of the proposed development is located within an “Area Under Strong Urban Influence” as designated in the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028. This is a rural area under strong urban influence in close proximity to Enniscorthy Town, where housing is restricted to persons demonstrating social and economic local need in accordance with the provisions of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028. It is considered that the applicant does not come within the scope of the housing need criteria as set out in the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028 for a house at this location. The proposed development would, therefore, be contrary to the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028 provisions relating to sustainable rural housing and to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Newhouse, Kilcowan, Wexford

Newhouse, Kilcowan

Wexford County Council · 20261067W

What was proposed

Permission for retention for boarding kennels and associated site works

Refusal reason

The potential for an unacceptable increase in noise generated from the development could negatively impact on the residents of neighbouring properties. The development is therefore contrary to Volume 1, Chapter 10, Objective N06 & N12 and Volume 2 Section 5.10.8 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028 and contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Hilltown, Ballymitty, Wexford

Hilltown, Ballymitty

Wexford County Council · 20261057W

What was proposed

Planning permission for the erection of a serviced dwelling house, garage and all associated and auxiliary site works

Refusal reasons
  1. The proposed development, in an area of relatively poor subsoil permeability, taken in conjunction with other domestic wastewater treatment systems in the vicinity, would be prejudicial to public health and the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. It is the policy of the Council, as set out in Volume 1, Objective 4.9.3 of the Wexford County Development Plan to ensure that a proposed development ‘would not result in or extend an existing pattern of one-off linear development’. The proposed development would create an infill site and would constitute ribbon development thereby exacerbating a suburban form of linear development within a rural area. The proposed development, taken in conjunction with existing development, would constitute an undesirable exacerbation of ribbon development in a rural area, which would further detract from the amenities and rural character of the area. The proposed development is therefore considered contrary to Section 4.9.3 Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028 (as extended), and to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  3. The proposed development is contrary to Volume 2, Objective 8.3.1 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028 in relation minimum site size requirements. The proposed development is therefore considered contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  4. Insufficient information and clarity has been submitted in respect of the surface water assessment for the proposed site. The proposed development would therefore be prejudicial to public health and the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  5. Insufficient information has been submitted regarding the requirements set out under Table 3-3 (Volume 2) of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028. The applicant has submitted no details in relation to a biodiversity tree or shrub planting proposal in order to provide the minimum requirement of 20% of the site area planted for biodiversity use. The proposed development is therefore considered contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  6. The applicant has failed to adequately demonstrate a housing need in accordance with the rural housing policy as set out in Volume 1 Table 4.6 (point 4 in Definition and Notes) of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022- 2028. The proposal is therefore contrary to the proper planning and the sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Ballynastraw, Moyacomb, Wexford

Ballynastraw, Moyacomb

Wexford County Council · 20261056W

What was proposed

Permission for the installation of 1 no. low impact off grid cabin, outdoor sauna, signage, and a proposed wastewater treatment system and percolation area, together with all ancillary and associated site works. Full planning permission is also sought for realignment works to the applicant's roadside boundary along the Class 2 Regional Road (R746) to improve sightlines, together with all associated works and services, at Brook Farm

Refusal reasons
  1. Section 8.7.2 and Objective TS74 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028, Volume One seeks 'to prevent new, or the material intensification of, existing access points to Class 2 regional roads where a speed limit of greater than 60 kmh applies (see Table 8-11 Regional Roads), except where a need for the development at that location has been clearly established and there is no suitable alternative access possible from a local road'. The location of the proposed entrance on the Class Two Regional Road has not satisfied this requirement. Furthermore, the location of the proposed entrance along a continuous white along the road surface and in proximity to a junction would be undesirable. It is considered that the proposed development would therefore pose an undue traffic hazard, would be contrary to the guidance contained within Section 7.7.5 and Objective TM56 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028, Volume One and would be contrary to the proposed planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. The proposed development would require the extensive removal of natural hedgerow and would represent an undue loss of natural features that would ultimately detract from the visual amenity of this rural area. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to Section 2.9.1 of Volume 2 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028 and contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  3. Inadequate information has been submitted to demonstrate that the proposed development would not pose a public health hazard in close proximity to a stream which has an indirect connection to Slaney River Valley Special Area of Conservation. The proposed development may therefore be contrary to Objective NH08 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028, Volume One.
  4. The proposed development, by virtue of the absence of a Natura Impact Statement submitted as part of the planning application, has not been accompanied by sufficient information for the Planning Authority to conclude that the proposed development would not adversely affect the integrity of a European site, either alone or in combination with other plans or projects. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to the requirements of Article 6(3) of the Habitats Directive (92/43/EEC) and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Theoil, Edermine, Wexford

Theoil, Edermine

Wexford County Council · 20261054

What was proposed

Permission for retention of an existing self-contained residential unit ancillary to the main dwelling with all associated site works

Refusal reasons
  1. It is the policy of Wexford County Council to consider the provision of a self-contained residential unit for use by a family member where the need for the unit has been clearly demonstrated, including details of the intended occupant(s), and where the unit is physically attached and integrated into the main dwelling house. Based on the information submitted, the application fails to comply with Section 4.9.5 of Volume 1 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028, whereby a detached log cabin type structure has been erected within the curtilage of an existing dwelling, which cannot be integrated into the main dwelling house. Furthermore, the design and material of the self-contained residential unit fails to comply with Section 4.9.6 of Volume 1 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028 whereby the Council will not give favourable consideration to modular structures where such structures are visually incongruous with the vernacular finishes in the locality. The development for which retention is sought is in essence a second detached dwelling on the site of an original dwelling, and if permitted, the development would set a wholly undesirable precedent for further development of this nature that is inappropriate and injurious to the amenities and character of this area. It is therefore considered that the development fails to comply with the policy and requirements as set out in Section 4.9 of Volume 1 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028, and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. The development, if permitted, would result in two separate dwelling units discharging to a single wastewater treatment system which is unacceptable, and would be prejudicial to public health. The development is therefore contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Ballina Lower (ed Kilmallock), Kilmallock, Wexford

Ballina Lower (ed Kilmallock), Kilmallock

Wexford County Council · 20261052W

What was proposed

Permission for retention for revisions to Section 47 to previously approved Planning Reference No. 20201029, existing storage shed/garage used for the incidental/ancillary enjoyment of existing dwelling and our lands and for alterations to site boundaries along with any associated site works

Refusal reason

The applicant is seeking permission for retention for revisions to Section 47 to previously approved Planning Reference No. 20201029. The Planning department cannot modify or change a legal agreement in the manner which is being sought. The applicant needs to apply for permission for retention of the erection of house granted in application 20201029 so that they can be assessed against the current rural housing policy detailed in Chapter 4 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028. Regularising the planning permission on any other structures on site can also not be done until such a time that the main dwelling permission has been rectified.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Carriganeagh, Courtown, Wexford

Carriganeagh, Courtown

Wexford County Council · 20260063W

What was proposed

Permission for retention of (1) extensions to dwelling and (2) retention of existing domestic garage. Permission is sought to erect extensions to dwelling and all associated site and ancillary works

Refusal reason

Having regard to the information submitted with the planning application, the Planning Authority is not satisfied that the proposed wastewater treatment system and percolation area can adequately treat and dispose of wastewater in line with the requirements of the EPA Code of Practice for Domestic Waste-Water Treatment Systems, 2001 and Section 8.31 of the Wexford County Development Plan 2022-2028. The site assessment report submitted as part of the application states that water remained in the test holes and the soils failed. The applicant has therefore failed to prove that the site is capable of safely disposing of the effluent generated by the proposed development meaning that the development may give rise to a public health and safety hazard. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

1 Great Georges Street, Waterford, Waterford

1 Great Georges Street, Waterford

Waterford City and County Council · 2678

What was proposed

Section 254 License Pavement A-Frame Sign

Refusal reasons

Reasons under review. View the official case.

Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Ongenstown, Bohermeen, Co. Meath, Meath

Ongenstown, Bohermeen, Co. Meath

Meath County Council · 2661002

What was proposed

the development will consist of the construction of a story & half detached dwelling & single storey domestic garage, with proposed O’ Reilly Oakstown EN Treatment system and a new site entrance onto public road with all associated site works and landscaping

Refusal reason

It is the policy of the Council, as set out in Policies RD POL 1 and RD POL 2 of the Meath County Development Plan 2021–2027, to manage the development of one-off housing in rural areas under strong urban influence. In this regard, the onus is on the applicant to demonstrate compliance with the rural housing policy and the local need qualifying criteria contained in Section 9.4 of the Development Plan. Having regard to the documentation submitted in support of this application, the Planning Authority is not satisfied that the applicant has sufficiently demonstrated compliance with local need qualifying criteria. In particular, the applicant has failed to demonstrate that they are an intrinsic member of the rural area of Ongenstown, and have resided in this rural area for a continuous period in excess of five years, as required under Section 9.4 of the Meath County Development Plan 2021–2027. Accordingly, the proposed development would materially contravene Policies RD POL 1 and RD POL 2 and the local need qualifying criteria set out in Section 9.4 of the Meath County Development Plan 2021–2027 and would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

The Ballymiles Inn, Ballymiles, Swinford, Co Mayo, Mayo

The Ballymiles Inn, Ballymiles, Swinford, Co Mayo

Mayo County Council · 26184

What was proposed

retain the existing 3 bedroom house and to change the use of the (unlicenced) premises known as the Ballymiles Inn to 3 no. 2 bedroom 1 no. 1 bedroom accommodation units together with associated site works. The application also includes a new access road and car parking associated with the residential development plus connections to services including a new waste water treatment unit and percolation area

Refusal reasons

Reasons under review. View the official case.

Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

The Brewhouse, The Square, Kenmare, Co. Kerry, V93VK02, Kerry

The Brewhouse, The Square, Kenmare, Co. Kerry, V93VK02

Kerry County Council · 2660743

What was proposed

retention permission to retain elevational changes made to the building and retain an extension at first floor level to create an enclosed fire escape route, and (b) retention planning permission to retain a single storey storage building at the rear of the property

Refusal reason

Based on the information submitted in relation to noise generated by the proposed development, Kerry County Council is not satisfied that the proposed development would not cause noise nuisance. Therefore, the proposed development would contravene Objective KCDP 11-36 of the Kerry County Development Plan 2022-2028, would seriously injure the amenities of residential properties in the vicinity and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

TRUMMAN EAST, LAGHEY, DONEGAL PO, CO. DONEGAL, Donegal

TRUMMAN EAST, LAGHEY, DONEGAL PO, CO. DONEGAL

Donegal County Council · 2661537

What was proposed

CONSTRUCTION OF A DOMESTIC STORAGE SHED WITH CONNECTION TO ALL EXISTING SERVICES AND ALL ASSOCIATED SITE DEVELOPMENT WORKS

Refusal reasons

Reasons not yet available here. View the official case.

Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

CNOC NA MUIRLEOG, NA DÚNAIBH, CO. DHÚN NA NGALL, Donegal

CNOC NA MUIRLEOG, NA DÚNAIBH, CO. DHÚN NA NGALL

Donegal County Council · 2661515

What was proposed

TEACH CÓNAITHE A THÓGÁIL, CÓRAS CÓIREÁLA FUÍOLLUISCE AGUS GACH SUÍOMH OIBRITHE A BHAINEANN LEIS

Refusal reasons

Reasons not yet available here. View the official case.

Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

AGHALATTY, CARRIGART, LETTERKENNY PO, CO. DONEGAL, Donegal

AGHALATTY, CARRIGART, LETTERKENNY PO, CO. DONEGAL

Donegal County Council · 2661503

What was proposed

CONSTRUCTION OF A STORAGE SHED INCLUDING ALL ASSOCIATED SITE WORKS

Refusal reasons

Reasons not yet available here. View the official case.

Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

STRACOMER HILL, TULLAN STRAND ROAD, BUNDORAN, CO. DONEGAL, Donegal

STRACOMER HILL, TULLAN STRAND ROAD, BUNDORAN, CO. DONEGAL

Donegal County Council · 2661495

What was proposed

(1) RETENTION OF EXISTING STONED / GRAVEL FINISHED PARKING / WORKING AREA AND VEHICULAR ENTRANCE ONTO THE ADJOINING ESTATE ROAD TO THE SOUTH OF THE EXISTING HORSE-RIDING ENCLOSURE, (2) CONSTRUCTION OF A STABLE BUILDING FOR KEEPING OF HORSES & ASSOCIATED STORAGE AND CONCRETE APRON / YARD, (3) CONSTRUCTION OF A ROOFED MANURE PIT, (4) CONSTRUCTION OF A PARKING AREA ON THE EXISTING STONED / GRAVELLED PARKING WORKING AREA AND UPGRADING OF THE ENTRANCE ONTO THE ADJOINING ESTATE ROAD AND (5) ALL ASSOCIATED SITE DEVELOPMENT WORKS AND CONNECTION TO THE EXISTING FOUL & STORM WATER DRAINAGE SYSTEMS AND ALL ASSOCIATED SERVICES

Refusal reasons

Reasons not yet available here. View the official case.

Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Nohaval Lower, Knocknagree, Mallow, Co. Cork., Cork

Nohaval Lower, Knocknagree, Mallow, Co. Cork.

Cork County Council · 26/2087

What was proposed

Permission to construct a new dwelling house and domestic garage served by mechanical aeration unit and soil polishing filter.

Refusal reason

2. As set out in the Cork County Development Plan 2022, it is a stated objective of the Council to encourage new dwelling house design that respects the character, pattern and tradition of existing places, materials and built forms and integrates appropriately into the landscape, in accordance with Objective RP 5-22. Furthermore, Objective GI 14-9 seeks to (a) protect the visual and scenic amenities of County Cork’s built and natural environment and (c) ensure that new development achieves high standards of siting and design. It is considered that the proposed development would constitute an inappropriate backland development detached from the established road frontage pattern in the area and would result in a fragmented and piecemeal form of development that would be out of character with the prevailing settlement structure. As such, the proposal would detract from the visual and landscape character of the area and would set an undesirable precedent for similar development. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to Objectives RP 5-22 and GI 14-9 of the Cork County Development Plan 2022 and, as such, would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Catfort Car Park, Friar Street and Stephen's Street, Cork, Cork

Catfort Car Park, Friar Street and Stephen's Street, Cork

Cork City Council · 26/44947

What was proposed

Permission for a change of use from existing car park/storage building (on 2/3 levels) to a retail unit with associated storage, service areas and office uses. This application also seeks permission for revised internal layouts, new entrances, revised new shopfronts and signage to Friar Street (East facing elevation), Stephen's Street (West facing elevation) and Tower Street Car Park (South facing elevation). This application also seeks permission for internal building upgrades including works to facilitate building regulation improvements and universal access, new windows and doors, works to existing foul and surface water connections to public services and all ancillary works. This development site is located within the 'Friar Street Area' Architectural Conservation Area as listed in the Cork City Development Plan 2022-2028.

Refusal reasons
  1. The application site is situated in an area zoned ZO 1 Sustainable Residential Neighbourhoods in the Cork City Development Plan 2022-2028, where the primary objective is to protect the amenity of existing local residential properties in the local area. Cork City Development Plan 2022-2028, paragraph 12.29 requires, development proposals in every zone must have placemaking as a primary consideration and must demonstrate how the proposal would respect, reflect or contribute to the character and vibrancy of the particular neighbourhood, centre or area, commensurate with the nature and scale of the development. Having regard to the scale of the proposed retail development, it would be of inappropriate scale within the context of the inner-city residential area. The proposed development would fail to support the primary residential function of the area, due to the potential of unacceptable impacts on existing residential amenities by virtue of its scale, increased noise pollution, general disturbance associated with the retail function, extended opening hours and traffic generation. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. The proposed development represents an excessively scaled edge-of-centre retail proposal which would result in an undesirable precedent for inappropriately scaled retail developments outside designated retail cores, thereby undermining the retail hierarchy as set out in Objective 7.27, Objective 7.34 and Objective 7.35 of the Cork City Development Plan 2022-2028, The proposed development would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Turners Cross Retail Park (Formerly Kinsale Road Retail Park), Kinsale Road, Cork, Cork

Turners Cross Retail Park (Formerly Kinsale Road Retail Park), Kinsale Road, Cork

Cork City Council · 26/44500

What was proposed

Permission for development at Turners Cross Retail Park (Formerly Kinsale Road Retail Park), Kinsale Road, Cork, Co. Cork. The development will consist of: The construction of 2 no. single storey cafe/restaurant units with ancillary takeaway use (Unit 1- 232 sq.m and Unit 2- 186 sq.m to be located within the western section of the existing car park of Turners Cross Retail Park. The buildings have an overall height of 5.2m and 4.5m respectively; Both units include ancillary 3.5m wide drive thru lanes, canopy and service hatch on the western elevation of the units, height restrictor/entrance barriers on the access lanes; The development includes associated drive thru directional signage, order stations and menu board/advertisement signage for both units and tenant signage is provided on all elevations for each unit; The development includes alterations to the existing car park including removal of existing steps to Kinsale Road and provision of new pedestrian footpaths to the north and east of the units; The development includes the removal of 72 no. existing car parking spaces and provision of 2 no. new accessible spaces and 3 no. EV charging spaces to the east of the proposed units and 12 no. cycle parking spaces. The development includes associated outdoor seating, soft and hard landscaping and external waste storage area and all associated development.

Refusal reason

Having regard to overall design of the scheme and inclusion of a drive-through and its associated infrastructure, the proposed development is deemed to be contrary to policies and objectives of the Cork City Development Plan 2022-2028, specifically Strategic Objective 3 – Transport and Mobility, Objective 2.14 – Walkable Neighbourhoods, and Objective 4.4 – Active Travel. By nature of its design, the proposed development does not integrate land use planning with the emerging transport plans for the city. The siting of a car orientated development at this location, specifically the drive-through element, fails integrate with the planned high-capacity BusConnects services that are proposed for Old Kinsale Road and fails to maximise access to the planned BusConnects route by providing a people focused development of scale and density. The proposed development includes a ring road around one unit, isolating the café/ restaurants from the primary walking route serving this district. The proposed development would discourage access by walking and cycling by not providing direct access for pedestrians and prioritising car movements over those wishing to access the restaurants by foot from the neighbouring community and would, therefore, fail to adhere to principles of proper planning and sustainable development.

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

17, Wheatfields Close, Clondalkin, Dublin 22, D22 PF57, Dublin

17, Wheatfields Close, Clondalkin, Dublin 22, D22 PF57

South Dublin County Council · SD26B/0365W

What was proposed

Retention for existing single storey garden room and permission for new extension link in rear garden to create family ancillary accommodation with internal modifications and associated site works.

Refusal reasons
  1. The proposed development, by reason of design, siting, scale and massing, and relationship to the existing built form and character of the area and by way of intensifying backland development in a residential area, would result in significant adverse impacts on the residential amenity of existing adjacent properties and the established residential character and visual setting of the area. The proposal would thus be contrary to the 'RES' zoning objective of the site, which seeks 'to protect and/or improve residential amenity'. Furthermore, the granting of permission of the subject development as proposed would set an undesirable precedent for other similar developments which would, in themselves and cumulatively, be harmful to the residential amenities of the area and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. Having regard to the scale, height, and overall massing of the structure to be retained and the structure to be permitted, and position of both relative to subject site boundaries, the development for retention would represent overdevelopment of the site and have an adverse impact on the amenities of adjacent properties by way of overbearing appearance. Additionally, the retention of this structure as constructed, if permitted, would set an undesirable precedent for development of similar scale which in themselves and cumulatively would be harmful to the residential amenities of the area, and thus contrary to the ‘RES’ zoning objective of the area, which seeks ‘to protect and/or improve residential amenity’. The development to be retained would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area and has not overcome the previous reasons for refusal under Reg. Refs. SD25A/0005W / ABP-322197-25 and SD23B/0417 / ABP-320115-24.
  3. Having regard to the built form, location and nature of the proposed corridor in conjunction with the “new family ancillary accommodation” and current unauthorised subdivision, concern is noted that the subject structure, by reason of its overall design and history, has the potential to continue to be used as habitable accommodation to be sold, conveyed, or leased separately from the main residence and unauthorised subdivision at the subject site separate to that of the main dwelling on site; that this would be contrary to Section 12.6.8 of the South Dublin County Development Plan 2022 – 2028; and it is not considered that a grant of permission would be credible and enforceable given the disparity between the representation of the site in plans submitted, and the extant subdivision of the site. A grant of permission would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Killinordanbeg Townland, Scramoge, Co. Roscommon., Roscommon

Killinordanbeg Townland, Scramoge, Co. Roscommon.

Roscommon County Council · 2660403

What was proposed

Permission for the construction of a dwelling house, domestic garage, the installation of a sewerage treatment unit and percolation area along with connections to all site services and all other associated site works at

Refusal reasons
  1. The proposed development, by reason of its scale, bulk and massing in conjunction with its proposed an siting at a considerable setback from the public road, would result in a development which is incompatible with the site, and which would fail to integrate into the landscape at this location. The development, if permitted, would result in a visually obtrusive feature in the context in which it is proposed and would, as a consequence be contrary to the provisions of Section 12.7 (Rural Design Considerations) and Policy Objective PPH 3.13 of the Roscommon County Development Plan 2022- 2028 (Volume 1) and would fail to accord with the siting and design principles set out in the associated County Roscommon Rural Design Guidelines. The proposed development would accordingly seriously injure the visual amenities of the area and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. Having regard to the previous refusal of permission on the site, which referred to the visual indicators of poor percolation on site, evidence of unacceptably high water table levels underlying the on proposed wastewater treatment system, and the sites location overlying a locally important aquifer and area of extreme groundwater vulnerability, the detail submitted in respect of the current application is insufficient to demonstrate that the site can attenuate and dispose of waste water safely and in accordance with the Environmental Protection Agency (E.P.A) Code of Practice 2021 for Domestic Wastewater Treatment Systems (Population Equivalent ≤ 10). It is therefore considered that the development has the potential to be injurious to public health and would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Killinagh Upper, Carbury, Naas, Co. Kildare, Kildare

Killinagh Upper, Carbury, Naas, Co. Kildare

Kildare County Council · 2660905

What was proposed

Dormer style house, effluent treatment plant, landscaping and all associated site development works.

Refusal reasons
  1. Policy HO P26 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied) seeks to “Sensitively consider the capacity of the receiving environment to absorb further development of the nature proposed through the application of Kildare County Council’s ‘Single Rural Dwelling Density’ Toolkit (see Appendix 11)” and “examine and consider the extent and density of existing development in the area”. Having regard to the level of existing development in the wider area it is considered that the proposed development would result in the further suburbanisation of the receiving environment and would erode the rural character of the immediate area and therefore would be contrary to the provisions of HOP26 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied) and to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. Objective HO O59 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 (as varied) seeks to “Carefully manage Single Rural Dwelling Densities to ensure that the density of one-off housing does not exceed 30 units per square kilometre, unless the Applicant is actively engaged in agriculture, or an occupation that is heavily dependent on the land and building on their own landholding.” In conjunction with the level of existing development in the vicinity which is measured at over 30 units per square kilometre, it is considered that the proposed development would exacerbate an excessive density of development in this rural area and would contribute to the increasing suburbanisation of the area. The proposed development would materially contravene Objective HO O59 of the Kildare County Development Plan 2023-2029 and would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Ferritersquarter, Dunquin, Co. Kerry, V92 V838, Kerry

Ferritersquarter, Dunquin, Co. Kerry, V92 V838

Kerry County Council · 2660474

What was proposed

Retention permission for minor single storey extensions, minor elevational changes and additional floor area to an existing dwelling house, for a stand-alone modular home office unit, for a garden shed and permission to retain the dwelling house, the septic tank system, the modular office unit and the garden shed all within revised site boundaries and permission to install a modular unit comprising kitchen-living accommodation and storage and all ancillary site works

Refusal reasons

Reasons under review. View the official case.

Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Glenamaddy, Co. Galway, Galway

Glenamaddy, Co. Galway

Galway County Council · 2661372

What was proposed

to demolish an existing dwelling house and outbuildings, and to construct 5 number dwellings, consisting of 2 number three-bedroom houses and 3 number two-bedroom houses, each with a connection to the public utility services. Permission is also sought for boundary treatments, surface car parking and all ancillary site works to the development

Refusal reasons
  1. It is considered that the proposed demolition and development is out of character and incongruous with the existing form and pattern of permitted development in the vicinity and would seriously injure the visual amenities within the Architectural Conservation Area of Glenamaddy. Accordingly, to grant the development as proposed, by reason if its demolition and design, would materially conflict with Policy Objective AH 4 (Architectural Conservation Area), SGV 12 (High Quality, Contextually Sensetive Design) and DM Standard 60 which seeks to ensure that development conserve and enhances the character and appearance of the Architectural Conservation Area. Accordingly, to grant the proposed development would interfere with the character of the Architectural Conservation Area, would contravene materially a policy objective and development management standard contained in the current County Development Plan, would detract from the visual amenity of the area, would militate against the preservation of the Architectural Conservation Area and would set an undesirable precedent for similar future development in the area, and therefore would be contrary to the proposed planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. Based on the lacunae associated with the proposal from a wastewater perspective, and considering the observations of the Department of Housing, Local Government & Heritage with respect to gravity flow and the potential hydrological link from the site to the adjacent SACs, it is considered that the development has, in the absence of satisfactory evidence to the contrary, the potential to adversely affect the qualifying interests and conservation objectives of the localised Natura network, and would therefore materially contravene Policy Objective NHB 1 Natural Heritage and Biodiversity of Designated Sites, Habitats and Species, Policy Objective NHB 2 European Sites and Appropriate Assessment, and Policy Objective WR 1 Water Resources, and DM Standard 50 Environmental Assessments of the Galway County Development Plan 2022-2028 and would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. The Planning Authority in conjunction with the application of the precautionary principle, consider that adverse effects on the integrity and conservation objectives of the European sites, cannot be ruled out, as a result of the proposed project. Therefore, the Planning Authority cannot be certain that the project will not adversely affect the integrity of designated sites in the immediate site environs, in light of the conservation objectives which would contravene materially policy objectives and a development management standard contained in the Galway County Development Plan 2022- 2028 and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  3. Based on the information submitted and having regard to (inter alia) the following lacunae: - the absence of a Road Safey Audit and auto track analysis pertaining to larger vehicles entering, exiting and circulating through the development as per TII standards section 4.3 Design vehicle DN-03060 GEO- Geometric Design of Junctions (priority junctions, direct accesses, roundabouts, grade separated and compact grade separated junctions) May 2023, - the layout lacking in terms of adherence with the Traffic Sign Manual and the design lacking in respect to compliance with DMURS best practice principles for access roads, turning bays, footpaths and vulnerable road users, - ambiguity regarding connection points pertaining to the storm water management system to serve the development and the lack of a public lighting report/scheme accompanying the application, the overall scheme is considered to be contrary to policy objectives NR 3 (Traffic and Transport Assessment and Road Safety Audit) and NNR2 (Safeguard Regional and Local Roads) & NNR3 (Design Manual for Urban Roads and Streets) of the Galway County Development Plan 2022 – 2028 and therefore if permitted as proposed, would interfere with the safety and free flow of pedestrians/traffic within the scheme and on the public road and would endanger public safety by reason of traffic hazard, obstruction of road users, or otherwise, and therefore would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  4. Based on submissions received and the lack of a satisfactory pre connection enquiry response from the water and wastewater utility provider accompanying the application content, it is considered that the development has, in the absence of appropriate evidence to the contrary, the potential to be prejudicial to public health, and therefore if permitted would therefore materially contravene Policy Objective WW 4, Policy Objective WS 4, and DM Standard 36 of the Galway County Development Plan 2022-2028 and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. 3
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Townlands of Lissaniska, Oakwood South, Cahernaglass, Ryehill Demesne, Carrowmore, Parkacurry, Killaclogher, Ballynaboorkagh, Cashlaundarragh, Corrafaireen, Shantallow, Carrowreagh East, Caherlissakill, and Laragh Beg, County Galway, Ireland, Galway

Townlands of Lissaniska, Oakwood South, Cahernaglass, Ryehill Demesne, Carrowmore, Parkacurry, Killaclogher, Ballynaboorkagh, Cashlaundarragh, Corrafaireen, Shantallow, Carrowreagh East, Caherlissakill, and Laragh Beg, County Galway, Ireland

Galway County Council · 2661362

What was proposed

A 10-year planning permission for the development of a solar farm on a site of 239 hectares consisting of the following: 1,031,319 sq. m. of solar photovoltaic panels on ground mounted steel frames; 32 no. MV stations on associated hardstanding; new internal access tracks; underground cabling and ducting including along public roads L7138, L7141, L3110, L7140, L31085, L3108, L7132, L7131, and L7129; new access points onto public roads L7138, L3110, L7141, L7129, L71383, and upgrades to existing access points are proposed on public roads L7141, L3110, L7140, L7132, L7129, and L71383; limited alterations to existing stone walls including the creation or widening of access openings and reinstatement works; security fencing; CCTV; drainage infrastructure; landscaping and biodiversity enhancement measures; Horizontal Directional Drilling beneath the disused railway line; temporary construction compounds; and all associated ancillary site development works. The proposed development will be operational for 40 years. This development is covered by the provisions of the Renewable Energy Directive III (Directive (EU) 2023/2413) and it is important to note that the planning application may be subject to section 34D of the Planning and Development Act 2000, as amended. When a notice issues in accordance with section 34D(b), the provisions of article 26A of the Planning and Development Regulations 2001 to 2025 shall apply

Refusal reasons
  1. Having regard to the sensitive nature of the lands proposed to be developed within the ‘Overall Project’, the inconsistencies within the technical assessments submitted, the lack of robust technical justification for the development at this location zoned ‘Less Likely Viable’ in the Local Authority Renewable Energy Strategy (LARES), and overall uncertainty regarding the proposed future application for the grid connection and substation, the Planning Authority cannot confidently assess the viability and integrity of the proposed development in this context. The proposed works are considered premature without the assurance of the viability of the necessary grid connection infrastructure at this location. To permit the development in this context would be premature and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. On the basis of the submissions made in connection with the planning application, the Planning Authority is not satisfied that the application has been made by an applicant who has (i) sufficient legal estate or interest in the land the subject of the application to enable the applicant to continue the existing use of, or carry out the proposed works on, the land, or (ii) the approval of the person who has such sufficient legal estate or interest. The applicant has not clearly and efficiently demonstrated all appropriate legal consents, and the development is considered premature on this basis.
  3. Based on the details received, the Planning Authority is not satisfied that adverse effects on the integrity of the Lough Corrib SAC [Site Code: 000297] in view of its conservation objectives cannot be excluded. Therefore, if permitted as proposed the development would materially contravene Policy Objective MEQ 2 Protection of the Environment, Policy Objective NHB 1 Natural Heritage and Biodiversity of Designated Sites, Habitats and Species, Policy Objective NHB 2 European Sites and Appropriate Assessment, Policy Objective WR 1 Water Resources, and DM Standard 50 Environmental Assessments of the Galway County Development Plan 2022-2028. Therefore, to permit the development as proposed, would contravene materially policy objectives and a development management standard contained in the Galway County Development Plan 2022-2028 and would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  4. Having regard to the deficiencies identified in the Environmental Impact Assessment Screening Report submitted with the application, the inconsistencies within the technical assessments submitted, the lack of robust assessments of the impact of the overall development, and the likelihood of significant effects on the environment having regard to the criteria set out in Schedule 7 of the Planning and Development Regulations, the Planning Authority is not satisfied that the proposed development would not be likely to have significant effects on the environment. In the absence of adequate information to carry out a robust Environmental Impact Assessment screening determination, the Planning Authority consider the proposed development would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  5. It is considered that proposed grid connection works will both directly and indirectly impact the public road carriageway and the scale of these units, combined with the associated infrastructure, would effectively sterilise the public roadway preventing Galway County Council from carrying out essential future works, restrict future new services, drainage upgrades, installation or extension of Group Water Scheme mains, and/or the provision or alteration of house service connections. The Planning Authority considers the proposed unacceptable and to permit the development as proposed, would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  6. Having regard to the subject site location within a flood zone, and the absence of detailed design requirements for PV panels within sensitive areas, the Planning Authority is not satisfied that the subject site is not at risk of flooding, cause or exacerbate such a risk at other locations or flooding in the future. Therefore, if permitted as proposed, the development would materially 4 contravene Policy Objectives FL 1, FL 2 and FL 18 of the Galway County Development Plan 2022-2028 and the Flood Risk Management Guidelines for Planning Authorities and Best Practice Planning Guidance Report for Large Scale Solar Energy Development in Ireland (ISEA) and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  7. The Applicant has not referenced or submitted evidence of any consultation with the ESB/EirGrid regarding the proposal presented in this planning application in relation to the overhead lines traversing the subject site in accordance with the Guideline Clearances for Solar Farm to DSO Overhead Network. Having regard to the submitted Site Layout Plan, which does not accurately demonstrate every location of all overhead lines traversing the site or demonstrate the appropriate separation distances required from the proposed ground-mounted PV layout, if permitted as proposed, the development would represent a safety hazard and would be contrary the to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  8. Having regard to the submission received from Uisce Eireann, the proposed development layout includes the potential to build over multiple existing public infrastructure assets and does not adhere to the separation distances as per Uisce Éireann’s Standards Codes and Practices. Therefore, if permitted as proposed, the development would represent a health and safety hazard and would be contrary the to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  9. Having regard to the proposed development access points, traffic and haulage routing being proposed onto/from public local road network where considerations of public road capacity, width, alignment, surface and structural condition/composition of this pavement, in conjunction with future maintenance requirements, would render the road network or any part of it, unsuitable to carry the additional HGV/ articulated rigids traffic likely to result from the proposed development(s). These matters, in conjunction with the suitability of the proposed external and internal traffic circulation regime and the potential for conflicting traffic movements to occur directly and indirectly to the local public road network due to restricted vehicle manoeuvrability within and adjoining the site which may negatively impact public road and vulnerable road users’ safety. The Planning Authority considers that if permitted as proposed, the development would endanger public safety by reason of traffic hazard, obstruction of road users or otherwise, contrary to CDP policy objectives NNR2, and DM Standards 28, and DM standard 33a of the Galway County Development Plan 2022-2028.
  10. The Glint and Glare Assessment submitted is considered inefficient due to direct and indirect impacts have not been satisfactorily addressed with due consideration to the control of development potentially affecting National Roads, as outlined in the DoECLG Spatial Planning and National Roads Guidelines for Planning Authorities (2012). Therefore, if permitted as proposed the development would endanger public safety by obstruction of road users or otherwise and would materially contravene DM Standard 70: Solar Energy of the Galway County Development Plan 2022-2028 and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  11. Having regard to the submission received from the DHLGH, the submitted Archaeology and Cultural Heritage Assessment is not in accordance with National Policy for protection of the archaeological resources and it is considered that the assessment process submitted is deficient and incomplete. Therefore, if permitted as proposed, the development would materially contravene DM Standard 61: Archaeological Conservation and Preservation of the Galway County Development Plan 2022-2028 and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. 5
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

33 Whitebarn Road, Churchtown, Dublin 14, D14C659, Dublin

33 Whitebarn Road, Churchtown, Dublin 14, D14C659

Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council · D26A/0593/WEB

What was proposed

The retention of unauthorised demolition of portion of front boundary wall and pier to widen vehicular entrance on to Whitebarn Road and of roofs, side chimney, rear wall, and portion of side wall to prepare for extension works, the reconstruction of front roof with gable end to replace hipped profile to include to lower half, widened hipped roof to cover converted garage and to upper half, shallow central dormer and opening for concealed terrace, the construction to the rear of flat roof ground floor extension with rooflight and roof overhang and of first floor dormer extension with sloped side setbacks roofs, modifications to ground floor wall openings to side elevation, the construction of new boundary matching entrance pier and all associated site works.

Refusal reasons
  1. Having regard to the nature and extent of the works undertaken and proposed, including the removal of the roof structure and significant elements of the external walls, the Planning Authority considers that the proposal constitutes, in effect, a substantial reconstruction of the dwelling. The Planning Authority is not satisfied that the extent of demolition has been adequately justified, having regard to the absence of a detailed structural assessment or engineering report to demonstrate the necessity for such works. In these circumstances, the proposed development is considered to be contrary to Section 12.3.7.1 and Section 12.3.9 Demolition and Replacement Dwellings of the Dún Laoghaire Rathdown County Development Plan 2022-2028, and to Policy Objectives CA6 and PHP19 which seek to promote the retention and reuse of existing housing stock; the proposal would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. The proposed roof alterations, including the rear dormer extension, front dormer, front roof terrace and reconstructed roof profile, fail to accord with Section 12.3.7.1 Extensions to Dwellings (iv) Alterations at Roof/Attic Level of the Dún Laoghaire Rathdown County Development Plan 2022-2028. The rear dormer, by reason of its position at the ridgeline and eaves and its scale relative to the rear roof slope, would not appear as a subordinate roof addition. Furthermore, the front dormer and associated roof alterations fail to have sufficient regard to existing roof variations within the streetscape and would not maintain harmony with adjoining and surrounding structures. The cumulative effect of the proposed roof alterations would appear incongruous and visually obtrusive. The Planning Authority is not satisfied that the proposed rear dormer openings has been demonstrated to protect adjoining residential amenity. The proposal is therefore contrary to Section 12.3.7.1 of the Dún Laoghaire Rathdown County Development Plan 2022-2028 in respect of design quality and the protection of residential amenity, and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

76, Iona Road, Dublin 9, Dublin

76, Iona Road, Dublin 9

Dublin City Council · WEB2975/26

What was proposed

New vehicular entrance from Iona Road and driveway to allow for the installation of an EV charging point and all associated site works at 76 Iona Road, Glasnevin, Dublin 9, D09 E6W2.

Refusal reason

The proposed vehicular entrance would result in the removal of on-street parking spaces on Iona Road to accommodate a private vehicular entrance, is contrary to Policy SMT25, Section 8.5.7, Section 4.1 and Appendix 5 of the Dublin City Development Plan 2022- 2028, which aims to manage on-street parking to serve the needs of the city alongside the needs of residents, visitors, businesses, kerbside activity, and accessible parking requirements. A reduced supply of on-street parking would detract from the convenience of road users and the residential amenity of surrounding properties for other similar developments on adjacent roads. In addition, the removal of part of the existing front boundary railings and granite plinth walls would injure the visual amenities and undermine the integrity of this Residential Conservation Area contrary to Policy BHA9 of the Dublin City Development Plan 2022-2028 and would set an undesirable precedent, and therefore, would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Ballyroughan Big, Borris, Co. Carlow, Carlow

Ballyroughan Big, Borris, Co. Carlow

Carlow County Council · 2660249

What was proposed

a dwelling house with services, domestic garage and all associated site works

Refusal reasons

Reasons under review. View the official case.

Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Cul Dara, Williamstown Road, Waterford, Waterford

Cul Dara, Williamstown Road, Waterford

Waterford City and County Council · 2660580

What was proposed

Indefinite retention of amendments to the estate road layout previously approved under Planning Ref. 2560299.

Refusal reason

Based on the details submitted with the planning application, it is considered that the retention of amendments to the estate road layout previously approved under Planning Ref. 2560299 would result in an area of public open space, which forms part of the development to be retained, which is not adequately over-looked and which is not considered to be usable open space due to the narrow width of the area, would result in a poor provision of public open space to serve the residential development and would thereby constitute a substandard form of development which would seriously injure the visual, residential and general amenities of the area and as such would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. t erfo

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

College Road, Ardmore, Co. Waterford, P36KV67, Waterford

College Road, Ardmore, Co. Waterford, P36KV67

Waterford City and County Council · 2660367

What was proposed

of existing wall structure than that of what was granted under planning application 01/836, condition number 2(a) [which comprised the removal of existing wall and permission for construction of a replacement wall set back 1.5m from existing wall].

Refusal reason

The retention of the front boundary wall would give rise to a traffic hazard at this location because the required visibility splays cannot be achieved or maintained at the existing vehicular entrance due to the presence of the wall in its current form and position within the visible sightline. The retention of the front boundary wall would therefore be contrary to Section 4.4.5 of the Design Manual for Urban Roads and Streets (DMURS) and Section 8.7 of the Waterford City and County Development Plan 2022–2028 and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. t erfo

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Carrickleck, Kingscourt, CO. MEATH, Meath

Carrickleck, Kingscourt, CO. MEATH

Meath County Council · 2661000

What was proposed

the development will consist of the following: 1) to demolish a habitable dwelling house and domestic sheds, 2) to construct a replacement single storied dwelling house and a detached domestic garage, 3) to close up and decommission an existing septic tank and soakaway and to install a proprietary wastewater treatment unit and percolation area, 4) to close up an existing site entrance and to construct new entrance gates, wing walls and piers along with a new front boundary consisting of a timber fence and native hedging, 5) all ancillary site works

Refusal reasons
  1. It is a policy (HER POL 21) of the Meath County Development Plan 2021-2027, “To encourage the retention, sympathetic maintenance and sustainable re-use of historic buildings, including vernacular dwellings or farm buildings and the retention of historic streetscape character, fabric, detail and features.” The proposed development would involve the demolition of an existing traditional vernacular dwelling. The Planning Authority considers that the existing structure makes a positive contribution to the rural historic character of the area and has not been demonstrated to be incapable of retention, repair, refurbishment or sensitive adaptation for continued use. The proposed development would, therefore, result in the loss of a traditional vernacular structure, contrary to the aforementioned policy provisions of the Meath County Development Plan 2021 – 2027 and be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. r
  2. It is an objective (HER OBJ 35) of the Meath County Development Plan 2021 – 2027, “To ensure that development does not have a significant adverse impact, incapable of satisfactory avoidance or mitigation, on plant, animal or bird species protected by law”. g The Planning Authority is of the view that the existing residential structures on the site have a in likelihood of containing roosting bats, nesting birds and rare, protected or invasive species. It is considered that development on the subject lands, more particularly that relating to demolition of the existing structures, requires a brief EcIA. The applicant has not submitted a EcIA with the application. The proposed development would therefore be contrary to the aforementioned objective of the Meath County Development Plan 2021 – 2027 and therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  3. It is a policy (HER POL 37) of the Meath County Development Plan 2021 – 2027, “To encourage the retention of hedgerows and other distinctive boundary treatments in rural areas and prevent loss and fragmentation, where practically possible. Where removal of a hedgerow, stone wall or other distinctive boundary treatment is unavoidable, mitigation by provision of the same type of boundary will be required.” The Planning Authority is not satisfied that the proposed removal of the existing hedgerow and ditch along the site frontage is necessary to achieve the required sightlines. The proposed removal would therefore be contrary to the aforementioned policy provisions of the Meath County Development Plan 2021 – 2027 and be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. C
  4. It is a policy (RD POL 48) of the Meath County Development Plan 2021 – 2027, “To ensure all septic tank/proprietary treatment plants and polishing filter/percolation areas satisfy the criteria set out in the Environmental Protection Agency ‘Code of Practice Domestic Waste Water Treatment Systems (Population Equivalent ≤10)’ (2021) (or any other updated code of practice guidelines) in order to safeguard individual and group water schemes”. The submitted Site Characterisation Report (SCR) does not accurately reflect the number of bedrooms proposed and consequently does not demonstrate that the percolation area has been 2661000 appropriately calculated for the proposed development. On the basis of the failure of the subject application to demonstrate that the development meets the minimum standards as set out in ‘2021 Environmental Protection Agency Code of Practice’. The Planning Authority is not satisfied that the subject site can cater for the safe and effective treatment and disposal of effluent in accordance with the necessary standards and therefore would be prejudicial to public health. r
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Ardrums Great, Agher, Summerhill, Co. Meath, A83WY45, Meath

Ardrums Great, Agher, Summerhill, Co. Meath, A83WY45

Meath County Council · 2660985

What was proposed

the application is to include the following. A) Raising the roof of the existing garage and extending the floor area to the rear of the existing garage to accommodate a home office and private GYM area at first floor level. B) Covered car port to the rear of existing garage at ground floor level, C) Enclosure of the existing open porch structure to the front of the house, along with all facilitating and associated site development works

Refusal reasons
  1. It is a policy (DM OBJ 50) of the Meath County Development Plan 2021 – 2027 that, All applications for residential extensions in urban and rural areas shall be of High quality design which respects, harmonises and integrates with the existing dwelling in terms of height, scale, materials used, finishes, window proportions, etc; inter alia. The proposed garage by virtue of its scale, height and design is considered to represent an inappropriate form of domestic structure which would be detrimental to the visual amenities of the area. The proposal would fail to remain subordinate to the parent structure and would diminish the character and visual integrity of the building, setting an undesirable precedent for other similar development and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. Based on the information submitted, in particular the absence of any documentation in relating to the need for the proposed garage extension, it is not considered that the applicant has demonstrated a justification or need for a garage of this scale at this location. The g proposed development would, therefore establish an undesirable future precedent for in developments of this kind and be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Acorn House, Graney Close, Sluggary & Dooradoyle, Raheen, Limerick, Limerick

Acorn House, Graney Close, Sluggary & Dooradoyle, Raheen, Limerick

Limerick City and County Council · 2660913

What was proposed

(1) change of use from existing physiotherapy clinic use to current medical centre use (2) Permission for change of use from dwelling/residential use to overall building use as a medical centre, (3) permission for change of use of existing domestic shed to medical centre use including all necessary internal and external alterations (4) the construction of a rear extension to Acorn House including all internal and external alterations, (5) alterations to existing car parking including the provision of bicycle parking, the construction of a new front boundary (in part) (6) associated signage, including all associated site development works

Refusal reasons
  1. The proposed development constitutes a larger-scale group medical practice and would not be subordinate to the existing residential use of the dwelling. Section 11.5.3 of the Limerick Development Plan 2022–2028 provides that larger-scale and group medical practices should normally be located within local, district and major Town/City Centre zonings and should not give rise to adverse impacts in terms of car parking, traffic hazard or residential amenity. Having regard to the scale and nature of the proposed use and its location on lands zoned Existing Residential, the development would be contrary to Section 11.5.3 and would, therefore, be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  2. In the absence of a comprehensive traffic assessment and satisfactory evidence that the development could be accommodated without exacerbating existing parking pressures or In creating a traffic hazard, the Planning Authority cannot be satisfied that the proposed development would not endanger public safety by reason of traffic hazard, obstruct the t. free flow of traffic or adversely affect residential amenity and would therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. a
  3. The development as proposed and the precedent which a grant of permission would set for similar type development, would constitute an over-development of the site, would injure the residential amenities and be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
  4. The proposed development by reason of scale and intensification of use would P seriously injure the amenities and depreciate the value of properties in this residential area. C &
Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet
Refused

Stradbally East, Weir Rd, Kilcolgan, Galway

Stradbally East, Weir Rd, Kilcolgan

Galway County Council · 26194

What was proposed

for extension to house, comprising covered patio area & garage

Refusal reason

The proposed development is located within a site boundary that differs from that permitted under Planning Reference 21/492, the parent permission relating to the subject lands. The Planning Authority notes that Condition No. 2 of Planning Reference 25/60 expressly requires compliance with the conditions of Planning Register Reference No. 21/492, including the demolition of the substandard dwelling house and decommissioning of the existing septic tank. The proposed revision to the site boundary would be inconsistent with the extent of lands subject to the parent permission The proposed development, if permitted would therefore lead to materially contravening a condition of permission attached to a grant of permission on the site under 25/60 and would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area. 3

Official decision evidence
Open official case Not linked yet