9 Clifton Lane, Monkstown, Blackrock, Co. Dublin, A94PK07 - ACA, Dublin
9 Clifton Lane, Monkstown, Blackrock, Co. Dublin, A94PK07 - ACA
Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council · D26A/0458/WEB
What was proposed
Planning permission for demolition of single storey annex and replacement with a ground floor single storey extension to side and rear along with internal rearrangements and refurbishment to existing 2 storey Mews building and provision of single off street car space. The application also includes the demolition of an existing single storey garage building that accesses onto Clifton Lane that provides parking for the primary residence, 9 Clifton Terrace. Parking for Clifton Terrace we look to provide within a new Garage structure for 3 cars with studio accommodation over, and car charging points. Access to the new garage shall be from adjusted existing gate access from Clifton Lane. All associated site works and landscape works including a temporary construction access of Brighton lane, which is in the curtilage of a Protected Structure, within an Architectural Conservation Area.
Refusal reason
RECOMMENDATION Pursuant to the Planning and Development Act 2000 (as amended), it is hereby recommended to REFUSE PERMISSION for said development for the reason set out in the Schedule hereto: 1. Having regard to the Objective A zoning of the subject site, the proposed development which includes new extensions to and refurbishment of 9 Clifton Lane and the construction of a 2-storey garage / studio in the rear garden of 9 Clifton Terrace, it is considered that, cumulatively, the proposed development(s) would seriously injure the residential amenity of 9 Clifton Lane due to the scale, height and massing and location on the common boundary of the proposed 2-storey garage (in addition to reduced private amenity space to 9 Clifton Lane), which if permitted, would have an overbearing impact and unacceptable level of overshadowing on the rear garden to 9 Clifton Lane resulting in a poor level of amenity for its residents. The proposed development is therefore, not considered to be in accordance with the zoning objective A, which seeks 'to provide residential development and improve residential amenity while protecting the existing residential amenities'. Accordingly to permit the proposed development, would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Official decision evidence